Boyle Leah Imogen, Boyle Alexander, Jay Sharon, Marnewick Jacques
General Surgical Registrar, Department of General Surgery, Tauranga Hospital, Tauranga.
House Officer, Tauranga Hospital, Tauranga.
N Z Med J. 2020 Nov 20;133(1525):96-105.
New Zealand's stated goal of eradicating COVID-19 included the enforcement of a national lockdown. During this time, a perceived decrease in hospital presentations nationwide was noted. This was also the experience of the Department of General Surgery, Bay of Plenty District Health Board (BOPDHB). We sought to quantify this reduction by analysing the frequency and severity of three common acute general surgical presentations; appendicitis, cholecystitis and diverticulitis.
Data on presentations of patients with appendicitis, cholecystitis and diverticulitis were retrospectively collected for the national lockdown period (25 March 2020-27 April 2020) and the immediate pre-lockdown period (21 February 2020-25 March 2020). Data collected included patient demographics, duration of symptoms, method of diagnosis, treatment, severity of disease, length of stay and complications.
A reduction of 62.2% was noted in the frequency of appendicitis during the lockdown period compared to the pre-lockdown period. Patients presented later during lockdown and had a higher complication rate (5.4% versus 42.8%). Similarly, a 39.2% reduction in presentations of cholecystitis during lockdown was found. The lockdown group of patients had a longer length of stay (6.9 versus 4 days) and only one patient (9.1%, 1/11) was managed with laparoscopic cholecystectomy during the lockdown period, compared to 52.9% of patients (9/17) over the pre-lockdown period. No difference in frequency or severity of acute diverticulitis presentations between the two periods was found.
The COVID-19 lockdown led to fewer presentations, but these were often delayed, with more complications and a longer length of stay. This could be partly explained by patient fear around exposure to the virus and reluctance to attend hospital. More research is needed to study the flow-on effects of the COVID-19 lockdown on surgical presentations.
新西兰宣布的根除新冠病毒的目标包括实施全国封锁。在此期间,全国范围内医院就诊人数明显减少。丰盛湾地区卫生局普通外科也有同样的情况。我们试图通过分析三种常见急性普通外科疾病(阑尾炎、胆囊炎和憩室炎)的就诊频率和严重程度来量化这种减少情况。
回顾性收集全国封锁期间(2020年3月25日至2020年4月27日)和封锁前即刻期间(2020年2月21日至2020年3月25日)阑尾炎、胆囊炎和憩室炎患者的就诊数据。收集的数据包括患者人口统计学信息、症状持续时间、诊断方法、治疗、疾病严重程度、住院时间和并发症。
与封锁前相比,封锁期间阑尾炎就诊频率下降了62.2%。患者在封锁期间就诊时间较晚,并发症发生率较高(5.4%对42.8%)。同样,发现封锁期间胆囊炎就诊人数减少了39.2%。封锁期间的患者住院时间更长(6.9天对4天),封锁期间只有1名患者(9.1%,1/11)接受了腹腔镜胆囊切除术,而封锁前这一比例为52.9%(9/17)。两个时期急性憩室炎就诊的频率或严重程度没有差异。
新冠病毒封锁导致就诊人数减少,但就诊往往延迟,并发症更多,住院时间更长。这可能部分是由于患者对接触病毒的恐惧以及不愿前往医院。需要更多研究来探讨新冠病毒封锁对外科就诊的后续影响。