European Centre for Environment and Human Health, University of Exeter Medical School, Knowledge Spa, Royal Cornwall Hospital, Truro, Cornwall, UK; Stockholm Resilience Center, Stockholm University, 106 91 Stockholm, Sweden(1).
Environment and Sustainability Institute, University of Exeter, Penryn, Cornwall, UK.
Environ Int. 2021 Jan;146:106275. doi: 10.1016/j.envint.2020.106275. Epub 2020 Nov 23.
BACKGROUND: Globally, there is increasing scientific evidence of critical links between the oceans and human health, with research into issues such as pollution, harmful algal blooms and nutritional contributions. However, Oceans and Human Health (OHH) remains an emerging discipline. As such these links are poorly recognized in policy efforts such as the Sustainable Development Goals, with OHH not included in either marine (SDG14) or health (SDG3) goals. This is arguably short-sighted given recent development strategies such as the EU Blue Growth Agenda. OBJECTIVES: In this systematic map we aim to build on recent efforts to enhance OHH in Europe by setting a baseline of existing evidence, asking: What links have been researched between marine environments and the positive and negative impacts to human health and wellbeing? METHODS: We searched eight bibliographic databases and queried 57 organizations identified through stakeholder consultation. Results include primary research and systematic reviews which were screened double blind against pre-defined inclusion criteria as per a published protocol. Studies were limited to Europe, US, Australia, New Zealand and Canada. Data was extracted according to a stakeholder-defined code book. A narrative synthesis explores the current evidence for relationships between marine exposures and human health outcomes, trends in knowledge gaps and change over time in the OHH research landscape. The resulting database is available on the website of the Seas, Oceans and Public Health in Europe website (https://sophie2020.eu/). RESULTS: A total of 1,542 unique articles were included in the database, including those examined within 56 systematic reviews. Research was dominated by a US focus representing 50.1% of articles. A high number of articles were found to link: marine biotechnology and cardiovascular or immune conditions, consumption of seafood and cardiovascular health, chemical pollution and neurological conditions, microbial pollution and gastrointestinal or respiratory health, and oil industry occupations with mental health. A lack of evidence relates to direct impacts of plastic pollution and work within a number of industries identified as relevant by stakeholders. Research over time is dominated by marine biotechnology, though this is narrow in focus. Pollution, food and disease/injury research follow similar trajectories. Wellbeing and climate change have emerged more recently as key topics but lag behind other categories in volume of evidence. CONCLUSIONS: The evidence base for OHH of relevance to European policy is growing but remains patchy and poorly co-ordinated. Considerable scope for future evidence synthesis exists to better inform policy-makers, though reviews need to better incorporate complex exposures. Priorities for future research include: proactive assessments of chemical pollutants, measurable impacts arising from climate change, effects of emerging marine industries, and regional and global assessments for OHH interactions. Understanding of synergistic effects across multiple exposures and outcomes using systems approaches is recommended to guide policies within the Blue Growth Strategy. Co-ordination of research across Europe and dedicated centres of research would be effective first steps.
背景:在全球范围内,海洋与人类健康之间存在着至关重要的联系,这方面的研究涉及污染、有害藻类水华和营养贡献等问题。然而,海洋与人类健康(OHH)仍然是一个新兴学科。因此,这些联系在可持续发展目标等政策努力中认识不足,海洋目标(SDG14)和健康目标(SDG3)都没有包含 OHH。考虑到最近的发展战略,如欧盟蓝色增长议程,这种情况可以说是短视的。
目的:在本系统图谱中,我们旨在通过建立现有证据的基准,进一步加强欧洲的 OHH 研究,提出以下问题:海洋环境与人类健康和福祉的积极和消极影响之间有哪些联系已被研究?
方法:我们搜索了八个文献数据库,并通过利益相关者咨询查询了 57 个组织。研究结果包括主要研究和系统综述,这些研究均根据已发表的方案,针对预先定义的纳入标准进行了双盲筛选。研究仅限于欧洲、美国、澳大利亚、新西兰和加拿大。根据利益相关者定义的代码本提取数据。叙述性综合探讨了海洋暴露与人类健康结果之间关系的当前证据、知识差距的趋势以及 OHH 研究领域随时间的变化。最终数据库可在 Seas,Oceans and Public Health in Europe 网站(https://sophie2020.eu/)上获得。
结果:数据库中共有 1542 篇独特的文章,包括 56 篇系统综述中检查的文章。研究主要集中在美国,占文章的 50.1%。大量文章发现:海洋生物技术与心血管或免疫状况、海鲜消费与心血管健康、化学污染与神经状况、微生物污染与胃肠道或呼吸道健康、石油工业职业与心理健康之间存在联系。缺乏直接影响塑料污染的证据,以及与利益相关者确定的一些相关行业的工作。随着时间的推移,海洋生物技术的研究占据主导地位,但重点狭窄。污染、食品和疾病/伤害研究也遵循类似的轨迹。幸福感和气候变化作为关键主题最近才出现,但在证据数量上落后于其他类别。
结论:与欧洲政策相关的 OHH 证据基础正在增长,但仍然参差不齐且协调不力。未来有相当大的证据综合空间可以为政策制定者提供更好的信息,但综述需要更好地纳入复杂的暴露因素。未来研究的优先事项包括:积极评估化学污染物、气候变化引起的可衡量影响、新兴海洋产业的影响,以及海洋与人类健康相互作用的区域和全球评估。建议使用系统方法来理解多种暴露和结果的协同效应,以指导蓝色增长战略中的政策。欧洲范围内的研究协调和专门的研究中心将是有效的第一步。
Ann Glob Health. 2020-12-3
Mar Environ Res. 2014-8
Health Promot Int. 2023-8-1
Mar Pollut Bull. 2006
Environ Res. 2021-8
Environ Sci Technol. 2025-7-15
Rev Fish Biol Fish. 2022