College of Dental Medicine, University of Sharjah, Sharjah, UAE.
Faculty of Education, University of Waikato, Waikato, New Zealand.
Aust Endod J. 2021 Apr;47(1):43-53. doi: 10.1111/aej.12464. Epub 2020 Nov 28.
This study aimed to evaluate the impact of errorless and errorful learning, on acquisition of root canal hand-instrumentation skills. Dental students prepared standardised canals of different diameters and curvatures. Learning involved minimising (errorless: n = 21) or maximising errors (errorful: n = 21). Students who had completed accredited pre-clinical activities provided comparative data (n = 17). During testing, the distal canal of a plastic mandibular molar was prepared, first as a single task and then under multi-tasking conditions. Performance was assessed by preparation accuracy and time. Differences were assessed using anova (P < 0.05). Performance in the experimental groups was similar during learning. When multi-tasking, errorful learners showed a deterioration in preparation accuracy (P < 0.05). In contrast, preparation accuracy and completion times for the errorless and comparative groups remained stable when multi-tasking. Errorless learning resulted in stable performance under multi-tasking conditions. Investigation of alternative approaches to learning motor skills in dentistry is warranted as such approaches may provide better outcomes, especially under demanding conditions.
本研究旨在评估无错误和有错误学习对根管手器械技能习得的影响。牙科学生准备不同直径和曲率的标准化根管。学习涉及最小化(无错误:n=21)或最大化错误(有错误:n=21)。已完成认可的临床前活动的学生提供了比较数据(n=17)。在测试期间,首先以单一任务,然后在多任务条件下,预备塑料下颌磨牙的远中根管。通过预备准确性和时间来评估性能。使用方差分析(P<0.05)评估差异。在学习期间,实验组的表现相似。在进行多任务处理时,有错误的学习者在预备准确性方面表现出恶化(P<0.05)。相比之下,在进行多任务处理时,无错误和对照组的预备准确性和完成时间保持稳定。无错误学习在多任务处理条件下产生稳定的性能。有必要研究牙科中运动技能学习的替代方法,因为这些方法可能会提供更好的结果,尤其是在苛刻的条件下。