IRTA, Centre de Recerca en Sanitat Animal (CReSA, IRTA-UAB), Campus de la Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Barcelona, 08193 Bellaterra, Spain; Office International des Epizooties (OIE) Collaborating Centre for the Research and Control of Emerging and Re-emerging Swine Diseases in Europe (IRTA-CReSA), Bellaterra, Barcelona Spain.
Departament de Sanitat i Anatomia Animals, Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (UAB), Barcelona, 08193 Bellaterra, Spain.
Poult Sci. 2020 Dec;99(12):6503-6512. doi: 10.1016/j.psj.2020.09.017. Epub 2020 Sep 15.
Identifying which diseases represent a priority is crucial to optimize resources for diagnostics, control, and prevention. Here, the impact of 111 poultry pathogens belonging to Viruses (n = 31), Bacteria (n = 33), and Other (n = 47) was assessed using the H-index. The overall mean H-indexes suggested that poultry Viruses have statistically greater impact than Bacteria, which in turn are statistically more relevant than Others. Among the 20 highest H-indexes, 45% were zoonotic, and almost a third was Office International des Epizooties-listed. Avian influenza virus (H-index 127), Salmonella enteritidis and Salmonella typhimurium (H-index 72), and Eimeria spp (H-index 70) ranked the highest in Virus, Bacteria, and Other, respectively. Pathogens that produce overt clinical diseases and economic damage, cause immunosuppression, and/or are zoonotic had the highest H-index scores. The evolution of citations of particular pathogens reflected severe poultry outbreaks and/or zoonotic outbreaks in relatively wide geographic areas. Also, the evolution of citations based on taxonomic groups mirrored major changes in poultry production practices and management throughout history. Thus, Others were the most cited pathogens until the 1970s and, following 3 decades of unpopularity because of widespread use of intensive production practices, regained importance in the 2000s thanks to welfare regulation changes. Citations for Bacteria increased especially from the 1990s onward, probably because of the ban of growth promoters in western countries and the need to find new control methods for bacterial and protozoal infections. In general, countries with the greatest poultry production and research budgets had higher research production, that is the United States of America (USA) and China. Interestingly, the United Kingdom was among the top research producers despite falling behind other countries in poultry production and research budget. Moreover, the USA exhibited the strongest poultry research production based on number and diversity of publications (Dcos-index). In conclusion, the H-index could be a valid, simple tool to prioritize funding or interest in poultry diseases, especially when used as a preliminary selection approach in combination with other metrics.
确定哪些疾病是优先事项对于优化诊断、控制和预防资源至关重要。在这里,使用 H 指数评估了属于病毒(n=31)、细菌(n=33)和其他(n=47)的 111 种家禽病原体的影响。总体平均 H 指数表明,家禽病毒的影响明显大于细菌,而细菌的相关性又明显大于其他病原体。在 20 个最高 H 指数中,有 45%是人畜共患病,近三分之一是世界动物卫生组织(OIE)列出的。禽流感病毒(H 指数 127)、肠炎沙门氏菌和鼠伤寒沙门氏菌(H 指数 72)和艾美球虫(H 指数 70)在病毒、细菌和其他方面分别排名最高。产生明显临床疾病和经济损失、引起免疫抑制和/或人畜共患病的病原体具有最高的 H 指数得分。特定病原体的引文演变反映了相对广泛地理区域内的严重家禽暴发和/或人畜共患病暴发。此外,基于分类群的引文演变反映了家禽生产实践和管理历史上的重大变化。因此,直到 20 世纪 70 年代,其他病原体仍然是被引用最多的病原体,在广泛使用集约化生产实践的 30 年里不受欢迎之后,由于福利法规的变化,它们在 21 世纪又重新变得重要。细菌的引文特别从 20 世纪 90 年代开始增加,可能是因为西方国家禁止使用生长促进剂以及需要寻找新的细菌和原生动物感染控制方法。一般来说,家禽生产和研究预算最大的国家的研究生产也更高,即美国和中国。有趣的是,英国尽管在家禽生产和研究预算方面落后于其他国家,但仍位列研究生产大国之列。此外,美国在出版物数量和多样性(Dcos 指数)方面表现出最强的家禽研究生产能力。总之,H 指数可以作为一种有效的、简单的工具,优先考虑家禽疾病的资金或研究兴趣,特别是在与其他指标结合使用作为初步选择方法时。