Radboud University Nijmegen, Houtlaan 4, 6525 XZ Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
European Food Safety Authority, Scientific Committee and Emerging Risks Unit, Via Carlo Magno, 1A, 43126 Parma, Italy.
Toxicol Lett. 2021 Mar 1;338:114-127. doi: 10.1016/j.toxlet.2020.11.014. Epub 2020 Nov 27.
In animal health risk assessment, hazard characterisation of feed additives has been often using the default uncertainty factor (UF) of 100 to translate a no-observed-adverse-effect level in test species (rat, mouse, dog, rabbit) to a 'safe' level of chronic exposure in farm and companion animal species. Historically, both 10-fold factors have been further divided to include chemical-specific data in both dimensions when available. For cats (Felis Sylvestris catus), an extra default UF of 5 is applied due to the species' deficiency in particularly glucuronidation and glycine conjugation. This paper aims to assess the scientific basis and validity of the UF for inter-species differences in kinetics (4.0) and the extra UF applied for cats through a comparison of kinetic parameters between rats and cats for 30 substrates of phase I and phase II metabolism. When the parent compound undergoes glucuronidation the default factor of 4.0 is exceeded, with exceptions for zidovudine and S-carprofen. Compounds that were mainly renally excreted did not exceed the 4.0-fold default. Mixed results were obtained for chemicals which are metabolised by CYP3A in rats. When chemicals were administered intravenously the 4.0-fold default was not exceeded with the exception of clomipramine, lidocaine and alfentanil. The differences seen after oral administration might be due to differences in first-pass metabolism and bioavailability. Further work is needed to further characterise phase I, phase II enzymes and transporters in cats to support the development of databases and in silico models to support hazard characterisation of chemicals particularly for feed additives.
在动物健康风险评估中,通常使用默认的不确定性因素 (UF) 100 来对饲料添加剂进行危害特征描述,以便将试验物种(大鼠、小鼠、狗、兔)中的无观察到不良效应水平 (NOAEL) 转化为农场和伴侣动物物种的慢性暴露“安全”水平。从历史上看,这两个 10 倍的因素都进一步分为在两个维度上包含化学特异性数据,只要有数据可用。由于猫(Felis Sylvestris catus)物种在葡萄糖醛酸化和甘氨酸缀合方面特别缺乏,因此还应用了额外的默认 UF 5。本文旨在通过比较大鼠和猫之间 30 种 I 相和 II 相代谢底物的动力学参数,评估物种间动力学差异 (4.0) 的 UF 以及应用于猫的额外 UF 的科学依据和有效性。当母体化合物发生葡萄糖醛酸化时,默认因子 4.0 被超过,齐多夫定和 S-卡洛芬除外。主要通过肾脏排泄的化合物未超过 4.0 倍的默认值。在大鼠中代谢的由 CYP3A 代谢的化学物质的结果混合。当静脉内给予化学物质时,除氯米帕明、利多卡因和阿芬太尼外,未超过 4.0 倍的默认值。口服后观察到的差异可能是由于首过代谢和生物利用度的差异所致。需要进一步研究猫中的 I 相、II 相酶和转运蛋白,以支持数据库和计算模型的开发,从而支持特别是饲料添加剂的化学物质的危害特征描述。