Borbas Paul, Eid Karim, Ek Eugene T, Ricks Matthew, Feigl Georg, Jeserschek Julian M
Department of Orthopaedics, Cantonal Hospital Baden, Baden, Switzerland.
Melbourne Orthopaedic Group and Department of Surgery, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia.
Shoulder Elbow. 2020 Dec;12(6):399-403. doi: 10.1177/1758573219869332. Epub 2019 Aug 12.
It is not known whether an anterior, posterior or superior approach using the Neviaser portal is more accurate for glenohumeral joint injections. The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of the palpation-guided technique and compare the three different approaches.
Palpation-guided glenohumeral joint injections were performed in 48 shoulders (24 cadavers) by two operators. Each shoulder was injected by three different approaches with a different coloured latex solution. The three approaches included the anterior, posterior and superior methods. The accuracy and location of unsuccessful injections were assessed through dissection of the shoulders.
Posterior injections were the most successful with an accuracy rate of 89.6%, followed by anterior injections (75%) and superior injections (54.2%). Both posterior ( = 0.0001) and anterior injections ( = 0.03) were statistically significantly more accurate than superior injections. The most common failure mode was an intratendinous or intramuscular injection, which occurred most frequently with a superior approach.
Use of a superior approach through the Neviaser portal for the palpation-guided technique for glenohumeral joint injections showed a statistically significant inferior accuracy when compared to both the posterior and anterior approaches and is therefore not recommended. Posterior approached injections were the most accurate.
对于使用Neviaser入路进行肩关节注射时,前路、后路或上方入路是否更准确尚不清楚。本研究的目的是评估触诊引导技术的准确性,并比较三种不同的入路。
两名操作者对48个肩部(24具尸体)进行触诊引导下的肩关节注射。每个肩部通过三种不同的入路注射不同颜色的乳胶溶液。三种入路包括前路、后路和上方入路。通过对肩部进行解剖来评估注射失败的准确性和位置。
后路注射最成功,准确率为89.6%,其次是前路注射(75%)和上方注射(54.2%)。后路注射(P = 0.0001)和前路注射(P = 0.03)在统计学上均显著比上方注射更准确。最常见的失败模式是肌腱内或肌肉内注射,这在上方入路中最常发生。
与后路和前路入路相比,通过Neviaser入路采用上方入路进行触诊引导技术的肩关节注射在统计学上准确性显著较差,因此不推荐使用。后路入路注射最准确。