Donhuijsen K, Budach V, van Beuningen D, Schmidt U
Institute of Pathology, West German Tumor Center, University of Essen, Federal Republic of Germany.
Cancer. 1988 Jan 1;61(1):68-75. doi: 10.1002/1097-0142(19880101)61:1<68::aid-cncr2820610112>3.0.co;2-e.
Human tumors transplanted into nude mice are widely considered to be identical to the tumor of origin. In addition, high histologic constancy of xenografts over many passages is generally accepted. We have checked these prerequisites for a therapy-orientated application of the nude mouse model using soft tissue sarcomas. Twenty-two primary soft tissue sarcomas and their xenografts were compared histologically and flow cytometrically over numerous passages. More than 30% of transplants showed a variation in cell differentiation, cell content, frequency of mitosis, tendency to necrotize, and connective tissue content compared to the original tumor. Furthermore, transplants from various regions in one tumor showed divergent results. Analyses of serial transplants showed histologic and flow cytometrical discrepancies in about 50% of cases, and new cell lines occurred in 26%. Our results show that the genetic instability found in human neoplasias also applies to xenotransplants and that the therapy-related usefulness of the nude mouse model is limited.
移植到裸鼠体内的人类肿瘤被广泛认为与原发肿瘤相同。此外,异种移植瘤在多次传代过程中具有高度的组织学稳定性这一点也普遍被接受。我们使用软组织肉瘤对裸鼠模型在以治疗为导向的应用中的这些前提条件进行了检验。对22例原发性软组织肉瘤及其异种移植瘤在多次传代过程中进行了组织学和流式细胞术比较。超过30%的移植瘤与原发肿瘤相比,在细胞分化、细胞含量、有丝分裂频率、坏死倾向和结缔组织含量方面表现出差异。此外,来自同一肿瘤不同区域的移植瘤结果也不一致。连续移植分析显示,约50%的病例存在组织学和流式细胞术差异,26%出现了新的细胞系。我们的结果表明,人类肿瘤中发现的基因不稳定性也适用于异种移植,裸鼠模型在治疗方面的实用性是有限的。