State Institution «National Research Center for Radiation Medicine of the National Academy of Medical Sciences of Ukraine», 53 Yuriia Illienka St., Kyiv, 04050, Ukraine.
Probl Radiac Med Radiobiol. 2020 Dec;25:543-557. doi: 10.33145/2304-8336-2020-25-543-557.
Loss of health and work ability, as well as deaths from diseases of the circulatory system (DCS), first of all arterialhypertension (AH), due to radiation exposure (RE) in the conditions of Chernobyl catastrophe (ChC) in the performance of professional, military or official duties and / or living on radiation-contaminated areas, additional exposurenot through their own fault but due to a radiation accident, caused the development of a special form of medicalexpertise as part of the of medical social protection system for these suffered contingents.
to optimize decision-making criteria for the expert estimation of the casual relationship between development and progression of AH under the influence of RE in clean-up workers of the Chornobyl NPP accident (CWs)in the remote postaccidental period based on the study of odds ratio (OR) of the course of the disease.
A retrospective analysis of the structure of 16073 cases of victims of the Chornobyl NPP(ChNPP) accident, considered by the Central Interagency Expert Commission of Ministry of Health of Ukraine for diseases, reason of disability and death causal relationship to ChNPP accident (CIEC) during 2014-2016, allowed toform a group of 401 cases of CW with AH to determine the OR of the course of the disease. The main group consisted of 330 CWs for whom the development of AH has a causal relationship with the participation in the work for liquidation consequences of the Chornobyl NPP accident (WLAc), the comparison group - 71 CWs in respect of whoma negative expert decision was made. There were not significant differences between both groups of CWs in doseof external radiation exposure (DERE) in the main group - (0.155 ± 0.085) Sv, in CWs of the comparison group -(0.135 ± 0.086) Sv (р = 0.868).
In the remote postaccidental period, HSC take the second place (39.62 %) in the structure of medicalexpertise of the causal relationship of the diseases development and progression with RE for all categories of victims of the Chernobyl accident. The share of cases of AH was 28.4% of the total number of cases considered CWs. Inthe structure of cases of relationship of diseases of CWs that led to death, the share of AH was 17.8 %. In CWs themain group the AH developed in (9.4 ± 6.2) years after participation in WLAc, which is on average 6 years earlierthan in the comparison group (р < 0.001). AH in the main group of CWs developed at the age of 5.8 years youngerthan in the comparison group (р = 0.0005). The need for inpatient treatment come 8.6 years earlier (14.6 ± 7.7years) than in CWs comparison group (р < 0.001). At DERE 0,05 Sv and over, increases the probability of developmentand progression of AH that has causal relationship with participation in the WLAc. For medical expertise of thecausal relationship of the AH development and progression with WLAc at DERE 0.20 Sv and over the significant evidence value have the next criteria: terms Somatoform Vegetative (autonomic) Dysfunction (SVD) development(within 3,5 years) and its transformation into AH (within 7 years), verification of the AH diagnosis (within 9,5 years),inpatient treatment for SVD or AH (within 15 years), vascular events (Acute Cerebrovascular Accident - Stroke(ACVA) - within 24 years after participation in the WLAc or 11 years after the AH diagnosed, myocardial infarction(MI) - within 22 years after participation in the WLAc or 10.5 years after the AH diagnosed), the establishment ofpermanent disability.
Radiation factor has an evidence influence on the development and progression of AH in CWs. Criteria ofthe development and progression of AH in CWs can be used for evidence-based medical expertise for estimation of thecausal relationship of the disease with the WLAc in the remote post accidental period at DERE more than 0.20 Sv.
基于比值比 (OR) 疾病过程的研究,优化清洁人员在远程事故后时期因辐射暴露 (RE) 导致动脉高血压 (AH) 发展和进展的专家评估决策标准。
由于在执行职业、军事或公务职责以及生活在辐射污染地区时遭受辐射,以及由于辐射事故导致的额外非自愿暴露,丧失健康和工作能力以及死于循环系统疾病 (DCS),尤其是动脉高血压 (AH),导致了一种特殊形式的医疗专业知识的发展,作为这些受影响人群医疗社会保护体系的一部分。
对乌克兰卫生部中央机构间专家委员会在 2014 年至 2016 年期间对切尔诺贝利核电站事故 (ChNPP) 疾病、残疾原因和死亡因果关系进行审议的 16073 例事故受害者进行回顾性分析,形成了一个由 401 例具有 AH 的清洁人员组成的组,以确定疾病过程的 OR。主要组由 330 名因参与清理后果而与 AH 的发展具有因果关系的清洁人员组成,比较组由 71 名对此做出负面专家决定的清洁人员组成。在主要组中的外部辐射暴露剂量 (DERE) 中,清洁人员之间没有显著差异 (0.155 ± 0.085) Sv,在比较组中为 (0.135 ± 0.086) Sv (p = 0.868)。
在远程事故后时期,HSC 在所有切尔诺贝利事故受害者类别的疾病发展和进展与 RE 的因果关系医学鉴定结构中占第二位 (39.62%)。AH 病例占考虑的清洁人员总数的 28.4%。在导致死亡的清洁人员病例结构中,AH 占 17.8%。在参与 WLAc 的清洁人员中,AH 在 9.4 ± 6.2 年后发展,平均比对照组早 6 年 (p < 0.001)。在主要组中,AH 在参与 WLAc 后 5.8 岁时发展,比对照组年轻 (p = 0.0005)。住院治疗的需求比对照组早 8.6 年 (14.6 ± 7.7 年) (p < 0.001)。在 DERE 为 0.05 Sv 及以上时,与参与 WLAc 具有因果关系的 AH 发展和进展的可能性增加。对于 DERE 为 0.20 Sv 及以上的 AH 发展和进展与 WLAc 的因果关系的医学鉴定,具有以下显著证据价值的标准:躯体形式自主神经功能障碍 (SVD) 发展的期限 (3.5 年内)及其转化为 AH (7 年内),AH 诊断的验证 (9.5 年内),SVD 或 AH 的住院治疗 (15 年内),血管事件 (急性脑血管意外 - 中风 (ACVA) - 参与 WLAc 后 24 年内或 AH 诊断后 11 年内,心肌梗死 (MI) - 参与 WLAc 后 22 年内或 AH 诊断后 10.5 年内),永久性残疾。
辐射因素对清洁人员中 AH 的发展和进展有证据影响。在 DERE 超过 0.20 Sv 的情况下,可用于证据为基础的医疗鉴定,以评估在远程事故后时期因 WLAc 导致的 AH 发展和进展的因果关系。