Zhao P, Yang M L, Chu G P, Jia Z G, Zhou X J, Lyu G Z
Department of Burns and Plastic Surgery, the Affiliated Hospital of Jiangnan University (Wuxi Third People's Hospital), Wuxi 214041, China.
Zhonghua Shao Shang Za Zhi. 2020 Dec 20;36(12):1130-1138. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn501120-20200901-00399.
To compare the difference of pro-healing effect of porcine urinary bladder matrix (UBM) and porcine acellular dermal matrix (ADM) on full-thickness skin defect wounds in diabetic mice. Thirty-six type 2 diabetic BKS db/db mice aged 10 weeks were divided into UBM group and ADM group according to the random number table, with 18 mice in each group and preoperative molarity of non-fasting blood glucose higher than 16.6 mmol/L. A circular full-thickness skin defect wound with 6 mm in diameter was made on the back of each mouse, and porcine UBM and porcine ADM scaffolds were implanted into the wounds of both groups correspondingly. Immediately after operation and on post operation day (POD) 7, 14, and 28, wounds were observed generally. On POD 7, 14, and 28, 6 mice of each group were collected respectively to calculate the rate of wound epithelialization, and then the corresponding mice were sacrificed after calculation, and the wound tissue was harvested to make slices. Six slices of the mice in the 2 groups on POD 7 and 14 were respectively collected to stain with haematoxylin-eosin (HE), and 6 slices on POD 7 and 28 had Masson's staining, which were used to observe histopathological changes and scaffold degradation. On POD 7 and 14, 24 slices of each mouse in the 2 groups were collected respectively to detect alpha smooth muscle actin (α-SMA) and CD31 positive expression denoting the growth of myofibroblasts and neovessels respectively and observe the distribution and activation of macrophages with immunohistochemical staining. The wound tissue of mice in the 2 groups on POD 7 and 14 was harvested to detect mRNA expressions of fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF-2), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), and transforming growth factor β(1) (TGF-β(1)) by real-time fluorescence quantitative reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction. The sample number of above-mentioned indexes in each group at each time point was 6. Data were statistically analyzed with analysis of variance for factorial design, test, and Bonferroni correction. (1) General observation showed that integration of UBM scaffold into the wounds of mice in UBM group on most time points was superior, and integration of ADM scaffold into the wounds of mice in ADM group on most time points was inferior. On POD 28, epidermis still did not form in some region of scaffold surface of wounds of mice in ADM group, while wounds of mice in UBM group were completely epithelialized. On POD 7, 14, and 28, wound epithelialization rates of mice in UBM group were respectively (22.4±6.4)%, (68.6±12.4)%, and 100.0%, all significantly higher than (4.5±2.2)%, (23.6±4.6)%, and (64.2±13.2)% in ADM group (=7.427, 9.665, 7.655, <0.01). (2) HE staining and Masson's staining showed that a large number of cells appeared in wound scaffold of mice in UBM group on POD 7; cells distributed in the whole region of UBM scaffold on POD 14; dermal tissue with structure similar to normal skin formed in the wounds and the fibrous morph of UBM scaffolds disappeared on POD 28. Only a small number of cells appeared in inside of wound scaffolds of mice in ADM group on POD 7; on POD 14, cells were sparsely distributed in ADM scaffolds; on POD 28, the morph of originally robust collagen fiber of ADM scaffolds was still clear and visible. (3) On POD 7, a large number of accumulated myofibroblasts and neovessels appeared in the lower layers of scaffolds of wounds of mice in UBM group; on POD 14, evenly distributed myofibroblasts and neovessels appeared in the upper layers of UBM scaffolds, and most vessels were perfused. On POD 7 and 14, myofibroblasts were sparsely distributed in scaffolds of wounds of mice in ADM group with no or a few neovascular structures perfused unobviously. On POD 7 and 14, α-SMA positive expressions in scaffolds of wounds of mice in UBM group were significantly higher than those in ADM group (=25.340, 6.651, <0.01); CD31 positive expressions were also significantly higher than those in ADM group (=34.225, 10.581, <0.01). (4) On POD 7, a large number of macrophages appeared in the lower layers of scaffolds of wounds of mice in UBM group; on POD 14, macrophages infiltrated into the internal region of UBM scaffolds, and M2 polarization occured without M1 polarization. On POD 7, a small number of macrophages appeared in the bottom of scaffolds of wounds of mice in ADM group; on POD 14, macrophages were few in internal region of ADM scaffold, and neither M2 polarization nor M1 polarization occurred. (5) On POD 7 and 14, mRNA expressions of FGF-2, VEGF, PDGF, and TGF-β(1) in the wound tissue of mice in UBM group were all significantly higher than those in ADM group (=7.007, 14.770, 10.670, 8.939; 7.174, 7.770, 4.374, 4.501, <0.01). Porcine UBM scaffold is better than porcine ADM in facilitating wound repair and dermis reconstruction of full-thickness skin defects in diabetic mice through the induction of myofibroblasts and macrophages immigration, the promotion of neovascularization and expression of pro-healing growth factors.
比较猪膀胱基质(UBM)和猪脱细胞真皮基质(ADM)对糖尿病小鼠全层皮肤缺损创面促愈合效果的差异。将36只10周龄的2型糖尿病BKS db/db小鼠按随机数字表法分为UBM组和ADM组,每组18只,术前非空腹血糖浓度高于16.6 mmol/L。在每只小鼠背部制作直径6 mm的圆形全层皮肤缺损创面,将猪UBM和猪ADM支架分别相应植入两组创面。术后即刻及术后第7、14、28天,对创面进行大体观察。在术后第7、14、28天,每组分别取6只小鼠计算创面上皮化率,计算后处死相应小鼠,取创面组织制作切片。取两组小鼠术后第7天和14天的6张切片分别进行苏木精-伊红(HE)染色,术后第7天和28天的6张切片进行Masson染色,用于观察组织病理学变化及支架降解情况。在术后第7天和14天,每组分别取24张小鼠切片,采用免疫组织化学染色检测α平滑肌肌动蛋白(α-SMA)和CD31阳性表达,分别表示肌成纤维细胞和新生血管的生长情况,并观察巨噬细胞的分布及活化情况。取两组小鼠术后第7天和14天的创面组织,采用实时荧光定量逆转录聚合酶链反应检测成纤维细胞生长因子2(FGF-2)、血管内皮生长因子(VEGF)、血小板衍生生长因子(PDGF)和转化生长因子β(1)(TGF-β(1))的mRNA表达。各时间点每组上述指标的样本量均为6。数据采用析因设计的方差分析、检验及Bonferroni校正进行统计学分析。(1)大体观察显示,多数时间点UBM组小鼠创面中UBM支架的整合情况较好,ADM组小鼠创面中ADM支架的整合情况较差。在术后第28天,ADM组小鼠创面支架表面部分区域仍未形成表皮,而UBM组小鼠创面已完全上皮化。在术后第7、14、28天,UBM组小鼠创面上皮化率分别为(22.4±6.4)%、(68.6±12.4)%和100.0%,均显著高于ADM组的(4.5±2.2)%、(23.6±4.6)%和(64.2±13.2)%(F=7.427、9.665、7.655,P<0.01)。(2)HE染色和Masson染色显示,术后第7天UBM组小鼠创面支架中有大量细胞出现;术后第14天细胞分布于UBM支架的整个区域;术后第28天创面形成了结构与正常皮肤相似的真皮组织,UBM支架的纤维形态消失。术后第7天ADM组小鼠创面支架内部仅有少量细胞出现;术后第14天细胞稀疏分布于ADM支架中;术后第28天,ADM支架原本粗壮的胶原纤维形态仍清晰可见。(3)术后第7天,UBM组小鼠创面支架下层出现大量聚集的肌成纤维细胞和新生血管;术后第14天,UBM支架上层出现均匀分布的肌成纤维细胞和新生血管,且多数血管有灌注。术后第7天和14天,ADM组小鼠创面支架中肌成纤维细胞稀疏分布,无或仅有少量新生血管结构,灌注不明显。术后第7天和14天,UBM组小鼠创面支架中α-SMA阳性表达均显著高于ADM组(F=25.340、6.651,P<0.01);CD31阳性表达也显著高于ADM组(F=34.225、10.581,P<0.01)。(4)术后第7天,UBM组小鼠创面支架下层出现大量巨噬细胞;术后第14天,巨噬细胞浸润至UBM支架内部区域,发生M2极化,未发生M1极化。术后第7天,ADM组小鼠创面支架底部出现少量巨噬细胞;术后第14天,ADM支架内部区域巨噬细胞较少,未发生M2极化和M1极化。(5)术后第7天和14天,UBM组小鼠创面组织中FGF-2、VEGF、PDGF和TGF-β(1)的mRNA表达均显著高于ADM组(F=7.007、14.770、10.670、8.939;F=7.174、7.770、4.374、4.501,P<0.01)。猪UBM支架在促进糖尿病小鼠全层皮肤缺损创面修复和真皮重建方面优于猪ADM支架,其机制可能与诱导肌成纤维细胞和巨噬细胞迁移、促进新生血管形成及促愈合生长因子表达有关。