Wahler S, Müller A, Koll C, Seyed-Abbaszadeh P, Von Der Schulenburg J M
St. Bernward GmbH, Hamburg, Germany.
Analytics Services GmbH, Munich, Germany.
J Mark Access Health Policy. 2020 Dec 28;9(1):1861804. doi: 10.1080/20016689.2020.1861804.
Adjuvant treatment options have become the standard therapy for stage III and IV resectable cutaneous melanoma. Two recent studies led to the registration of dabrafenib and trametinib as targeted therapies for BRAF-mutated melanoma, and of immunotherapy with nivolumab irrespective of BRAF-mutation status. Both therapies have different spectrums of adverse events. To estimate the financial impact of side effects from the perspective of the German statutory sick funds to compare both therapeutic options and to relate the burden to the overall costs of the treatment.
Thirty-six adverse event categories for the combination of dabrafenib and trametinib ('combi treatment') and for nivolumab were extracted from the original publications of the studies named COMBI-AD and CheckMate 238.
For all event categories a diagnosis and therapy recommendation were determined according to current national or international guidelines or from leading German textbooks.
The resulting diagnostic steps, treatments, and therapies were evaluated with unit costs based on the German fee schedule for ambulatory physicians, the German G-DRG scheme, and the German drug price list.
The number of events with nivolumab per one hundred treatments amounted to 3.8 mandatory hospitalizations, 3.5 emergency care events and 0.8 life-threatening events. For the combi treatment, the respective number of events per one hundred treatments was 2.7, 1.8, and 0.5. The overall cost burden was calculated as €899 for nivolumab and €861 for combi-treatment.
The treatment of adverse events resulting from adjuvant melanoma therapy showed comparable costs for both therapies.
辅助治疗方案已成为 III 期和 IV 期可切除皮肤黑色素瘤的标准治疗方法。最近的两项研究促使达拉非尼和曲美替尼被注册为 BRAF 突变型黑色素瘤的靶向治疗药物,以及纳武利尤单抗免疫治疗(无论 BRAF 突变状态如何)。这两种疗法的不良事件谱不同。为了从德国法定疾病基金的角度评估副作用的财务影响,以比较两种治疗方案并将负担与治疗的总成本相关联。
从名为 COMBI-AD 和 CheckMate 238 的研究原始出版物中提取了达拉非尼和曲美替尼联合治疗(“联合治疗”)以及纳武利尤单抗的 36 种不良事件类别。
对于所有事件类别,根据当前国家或国际指南或德国主要教科书确定诊断和治疗建议。
根据德国门诊医生收费标准、德国诊断相关分组方案和德国药品价格表,用单位成本对由此产生的诊断步骤、治疗和疗法进行评估。
每 100 次治疗中纳武利尤单抗导致的事件数为 3.8 次强制住院、3.5 次急诊事件和 0.8 次危及生命的事件。对于联合治疗,每 100 次治疗中相应的事件数分别为 2.7 次、1.8 次和 0.5 次。纳武利尤单抗的总体成本负担计算为 899 欧元,联合治疗为 861 欧元。
辅助性黑色素瘤治疗产生的不良事件的治疗在两种疗法中显示出相当的成本。