Boffetta Paolo, Zunarelli Carlotta, Borron Claire
Stony Brook Cancer Center, Stony Brook University, NY, USA.
Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, University of Bologna, Italy.
Dose Response. 2020 Oct 21;18(4):1559325820957823. doi: 10.1177/1559325820957823. eCollection 2020 Oct-Dec.
Exposure to high arsenic concentrations in drinking water has been associated with skin lesions. Our goal was to conduct a systematic review of studies on skin lesions and arsenic exposure, with emphasis on results at low level of exposure.
We conducted a systematic review of studies reporting estimates of either prevalence or risk of skin lesions associated with exposure to more than 2 levels of arsenic in drinking water. We reviewed and abstracted the relevant results, with the aim of conducting a dose-response meta-analysis.
Nine studies of skin lesions were reviewed. Strong heterogeneity in the results did not meet the criteria for performing a meta-analysis. The relative risks for an increase of 10 μg/L arsenic in drinking water ranged from 1.002 to 1.140 (p-value of heterogeneity < 0.0001). Protection from bias and confounding was inadequate in most studies.
Current studies are inadequate to conduct meta-analysis on dose-response relationship between exposure to arsenic in drinking water and skin lesions. Studies with complete exposure histories indicate skin lesions are associated with arsenic exposure in excess of 50 µg/L or higher.
饮用水中高砷浓度暴露与皮肤病变有关。我们的目标是对皮肤病变与砷暴露的研究进行系统综述,重点关注低暴露水平下的结果。
我们对报告饮用水中接触超过两个砷水平与皮肤病变患病率或风险估计值的研究进行了系统综述。我们审查并提取了相关结果,旨在进行剂量反应荟萃分析。
审查了9项关于皮肤病变的研究。结果中存在强烈的异质性,不符合进行荟萃分析的标准。饮用水中砷含量每增加10μg/L的相对风险范围为1.002至1.140(异质性p值<0.0001)。大多数研究在避免偏倚和混杂方面做得不够。
目前的研究不足以对饮用水中砷暴露与皮肤病变之间的剂量反应关系进行荟萃分析。具有完整暴露史的研究表明,皮肤病变与超过50μg/L或更高的砷暴露有关。