Duclos Martine, Lacomme Philippe, Lambert Celine, Pereira Bruno, Ren Libo, Fleury Gerard, Ovigneur Hervé, Deschamps Thibault, Fearnbach Nicole, Vanhelst Jérémy, Toussaint Jean-François, Thivel David
Department of Sport Medicine and Functional Explorations, G. Montpied University Hospital, Clermont-Ferrand, France.
INRA, UMR 1019, UNH, CRNH Auvergne, Clermont-Ferrand, France.
J Sports Med Phys Fitness. 2022 Mar;62(3):404-411. doi: 10.23736/S0022-4707.21.12203-0. Epub 2021 Mar 9.
While academic achievement has been associated with physical activity, the present work questions the potential association between the physical fitness level of adolescents and the type of school they attend, ranging from academic to technical schools.
The Diagnoform Test was performed by 20,228 young French students from 76 schools (9196 females), mean age 15.8±1.8 years. This dataset includes two higher education institutions (N.=870), 37 general high schools (N.=13,125), 18 professional-oriented high schools (N.=3569), 5 agricultural high schools (N.=132), 2 vocational training centers (N.=202) and 12 rural vocational training centers (N.=1137).
In higher education institutions and general high schools, girls showed better performances for all physical tests. A decreasing Quotient of overall Physical fitness Condition (QPC) was observed for both genders from urban higher education schools to rural and technical institutions (P<0.001). The proportion of total variance accounting for within institution variation is strong (intra-class correlation coefficients [ICC] 0.20 [0.15; 0.27] for QPC).
The lower physical fitness level observed here among students from technical or training schools places them at higher risks for the development of future chronic diseases. These results suggest that specific interventions are needed depending on the educational setting.
虽然学业成绩与体育活动有关,但本研究对青少年的体能水平与他们就读的学校类型(从学术性学校到技术学校)之间的潜在关联提出了质疑。
来自76所学校的20228名法国青年学生(9196名女性)进行了诊断式测试,平均年龄15.8±1.8岁。该数据集包括两所高等教育机构(N = 870)、37所普通高中(N = 13125)、18所职业高中(N = 3569)、5所农业高中(N = 132)、2所职业培训中心(N = 202)和12所农村职业培训中心(N = 1137)。
在高等教育机构和普通高中,女生在所有体能测试中表现更好。从城市高等教育学校到农村和技术学校,男女的总体体能状况商数(QPC)均呈下降趋势(P<0.001)。机构内部变异占总变异的比例很大(QPC的组内相关系数[ICC]为0.20[0.15;0.27])。
在此观察到技术学校或培训学校的学生体能水平较低,这使他们未来患慢性病的风险更高。这些结果表明,需要根据教育环境进行具体干预。