Department of Genetics, CHEO, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Clinical Research Unit, CHEO, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Am J Med Genet A. 2021 Jun;185(6):1757-1766. doi: 10.1002/ajmg.a.62167. Epub 2021 Mar 15.
Neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) are genetically heterogeneous. There are many possible etiological investigations for NDDs, and a lack of clear and current guidelines for such testing. Here we characterize the practices of genetic and metabolic physicians in Canada as it pertains to etiological investigation of patients with NDDs, by means of an online questionnaire. The survey response rate was 30% (n = 46). The most commonly ordered first-line tests for patients with non-syndromic NDDs are chromosomal microarray (98%) and Fragile X testing (85%). The most commonly ordered second-line test for non-syndromic NDDs is a multi-gene panel (78%) or exome sequencing (29%). Biochemical screening is ordered as a first line test by 33% of respondents, second line by 31%, and rarely or never by 36% of respondents. Those respondents with metabolics fellowship training were more likely to order biochemical screening than those without. The number of years of clinical experience generally did not affect the types of tests ordered. For patients with NDDs, test-ordering practice among Canadian clinical geneticists is highly variable, in particular with respect to biochemical screening and use of next-generation sequencing technologies. Evidence-based guidelines should be developed to facilitate best practices in Canada.
神经发育障碍(NDDs)具有遗传异质性。有许多可能的病因学研究可以用于 NDDs,但缺乏明确和当前的测试指南。我们通过在线问卷,描述了加拿大遗传和代谢医师在 NDD 患者病因学研究方面的实践。调查的回复率为 30%(n=46)。对于非综合征性 NDD 患者,最常开的一线检测是染色体微阵列(98%)和脆性 X 检测(85%)。对于非综合征性 NDDs,最常开的二线检测是多基因panel(78%)或外显子组测序(29%)。33%的受访者将生化筛查作为一线检测,31%作为二线检测,36%的受访者很少或从不进行生化筛查。有代谢学研究培训的受访者比没有的受访者更有可能开生化筛查。临床经验年限一般不会影响所开检测的类型。对于 NDD 患者,加拿大临床遗传学家的检测开单实践差异很大,特别是在生化筛查和使用下一代测序技术方面。应制定循证指南,以促进加拿大的最佳实践。