Policy and Economic Research, International Vaccine Institute, Gwanak-gu, Korea
Department of Health, County government of Nyandarua, Ol Kalou, Kenya.
BMJ Open. 2021 Mar 23;11(3):e044615. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2020-044615.
To estimate the economic burden of cholera in Africa.
Cholera affected 44 countries in Africa.
The analysis used data from public sources in Africa published until September 2019.
Based on existing data from field-based cost-of-illness studies, estimated cholera incidence rates, and reported cholera cases to WHO, this research estimates the economic burden of cholera in Africa from a societal perspective with 2015 as the base year. The estimate included out-of-pocket costs, public health system costs, productivity loss related to illness and an optional productivity loss related to premature deaths valued by the human capital approach. As various input data such as cholera incidence, hospitalisation rates and the number of workdays lost were not well defined, a series of scenario analyses and uncertainty analyses, accounting for unknowns and data variability, was conducted. Similarly, the value of time lost due to illness and deaths using the human capital approach was explored through scenario analyses.
In 2015, an estimated 1 008 642 cases in 44 African countries resulted in an economic burden of US$130 million from cholera-related illness and its treatment. When the estimated 38 104 cholera deaths were included in the analysis, the economic burden increased to US$1 billion or international $2.4 billion for the same year. At the same time, when only the 71 126 cases and 937 deaths reported to the WHO are considered, the economic burden was only US$68 million for the year 2015. The estimates of economic burden are thus heavily dependent on the cholera incidence rate, how time lost due to illness and deaths are calculated, hospitalisation rates and hospitalisation costs.
The findings can be used as an economic justification for cholera control in Africa and for generating value-for-money evidence to underpin Ending Cholera-A Global Roadmap to 2030 with considerations to study limitations.
估算非洲霍乱的经济负担。
霍乱影响了非洲的 44 个国家。
该分析使用了截至 2019 年 9 月在非洲发布的公共来源数据。
基于现有基于实地成本效益研究的疾病发生率数据、向世卫组织报告的霍乱病例,本研究从社会角度出发,以 2015 年为基准年,估算了非洲霍乱的经济负担。该估算包括自付费用、公共卫生系统成本、与疾病相关的生产力损失以及可选的按人力资本法计算的与过早死亡相关的生产力损失。由于各种投入数据(如霍乱发病率、住院率和丧失工作日数)定义不明确,因此进行了一系列情景分析和不确定性分析,以考虑未知因素和数据变异性。同样,通过情景分析探讨了按人力资本法计算的因疾病和死亡而丧失的时间的价值。
2015 年,在非洲的 44 个国家中,估计有 1008642 例病例,导致与霍乱相关的疾病及其治疗费用为 1.3 亿美元。当将估计的 38104 例霍乱死亡病例纳入分析时,同年经济负担增加到 10 亿美元或国际 240 亿美元。与此同时,如果只考虑向世卫组织报告的 71126 例病例和 937 例死亡病例,2015 年的经济负担仅为 6800 万美元。因此,经济负担的估计严重依赖于霍乱发病率、如何计算因疾病和死亡而丧失的时间、住院率和住院费用。
这些发现可作为在非洲控制霍乱的经济依据,并为支持《2030 年全球消除霍乱路线图》提供物有所值的证据,同时考虑到研究限制。