Rajendran Sibi, Antonios Joseph, Solomon Beth, Kim H Jeffrey, Wu Tianxia, Smirniotopoulos James, Scott Gretchen, Benzo Sarah, Hayes Christina, Heiss John D, Chittiboina Prashant
Surgical Neurology Branch, National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (NINDS), Bethesda, Maryland, United States.
Department of Neurosurgery, Houston Methodist, Houston, Texas, United States.
J Neurol Surg B Skull Base. 2021 Apr;82(2):244-250. doi: 10.1055/s-0039-1694054. Epub 2019 Sep 18.
Neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2) patients report that swallowing and speech problems significantly affect their quality of life, but the etiology of these phenomena is poorly understood. Swallowing and speech deficits may arise due to the neuropathy of involved nerves, due to posterior fossa tumor growth, or as iatrogenic effects from neurosurgical procedures to remove these tumors. This study aims to identify the natural history of swallowing and speech deficits in an NF2 cohort and to characterize the factors that may lead to those deficits. Subjects ( = 168) were enrolled in a prospective, longitudinal study of NF2 with yearly imaging and clinical exams. The patients completed a self-reported questionnaire that included responses regarding subjective swallowing and speech dysfunction. A formal speech-language pathology evaluation and modified barium swallow (MBS) study (reported as American Speech-Language Hearing Association [ASHA] swallowing independency score from 1 through 7) was obtained when a speech/swallowing deficit was reported on the questionnaire. Of the 168 enrolled subjects, 55 (33%, median age = 31 years) reported subjective speech and/or swallowing deficits. These patients underwent one ( = 37) or multiple ( = 18) MBS studies during 44.8 ± 10.4 months follow-up. During MBS, a majority demonstrated near-normal swallowing (ASHA score >6, 82%), and no evidence of aspiration (aspiration/laryngeal penetration score = 1, 96%). Prior to initial MBS consultation, 38 (69%) patients had undergone relevant neurosurgical procedures. In those with recent (<1 week) posterior fossa surgery ( = 12), 2 (17%) patients had severe dysphagia and high aspiration risk on postoperative MBS. Both of these patients recovered to functionally independent swallowing status. Unilateral ( = 10) or bilateral ( = 6) tongue deficits unrelated to previous history suggestive of hypoglossal nerve injury were detected on clinical examination. There was a correlation between the presence of dysarthria and tongue deficits and tumors associated with the hypoglossal canal noted on imaging. A large proportion of patients with NF2 report speech and swallow deficits that are not evident on objective measurements. We also found hypoglossal neuropathy unrelated to prior surgical interventions. Our findings suggest that swallowing and speech problems in NF2 are associated with lower cranial nerve neuropathy, some due to compressive effects of posterior fossa tumors. Adaptation over the course of the disease allows for the compensation of these deficits and subsequent normal findings on objective testing.
2型神经纤维瘤病(NF2)患者报告称,吞咽和言语问题严重影响他们的生活质量,但对这些现象的病因了解甚少。吞咽和言语功能障碍可能是由于受累神经的神经病变、后颅窝肿瘤生长,或因切除这些肿瘤的神经外科手术的医源性影响所致。本研究旨在确定NF2队列中吞咽和言语功能障碍的自然病程,并描述可能导致这些功能障碍的因素。 研究对象(n = 168)纳入了一项关于NF2的前瞻性纵向研究,每年进行影像学和临床检查。患者完成一份自我报告问卷,其中包括关于主观吞咽和言语功能障碍的回答。当问卷中报告有言语/吞咽功能障碍时,进行正式的言语病理学评估和改良钡餐吞咽(MBS)研究(报告为美国言语语言听力协会[ASHA]吞咽独立评分,范围为1至7)。 在168名纳入研究的对象中,55名(33%,中位年龄 = 31岁)报告有主观言语和/或吞咽功能障碍。这些患者在44.8±10.4个月的随访期间接受了一次(n = 37)或多次(n = 18)MBS研究。在MBS检查中,大多数患者吞咽功能接近正常(ASHA评分>6,82%),且无误吸证据(误吸/喉穿透评分 = 1,96%)。在首次MBS会诊前,38名(69%)患者接受了相关神经外科手术。在近期(<1周)接受后颅窝手术的患者(n = 12)中,2名(17%)患者术后MBS检查显示有严重吞咽困难和高误吸风险。这两名患者均恢复到功能独立的吞咽状态。临床检查发现10名单侧或6名双侧舌功能障碍与既往提示舌下神经损伤的病史无关。言语障碍和舌功能障碍的存在与影像学上发现的与舌下神经管相关的肿瘤之间存在相关性。 很大一部分NF2患者报告有言语和吞咽功能障碍,但客观测量中并不明显。我们还发现了与先前手术干预无关的舌下神经病变。我们的研究结果表明,NF2患者的吞咽和言语问题与低位颅神经病变有关,部分原因是后颅窝肿瘤的压迫作用。疾病过程中的适应使得这些功能障碍得到代偿,随后客观检查结果正常。