评估医学生对电子烟的看法、使用情况及与电子烟相关的教育:一项试点研究。
Assessing Vaping Views, Usage, and Vaping-Related Education Among Medical Students: A Pilot Study.
作者信息
Ruppel Tyler, Alexander Brooke, Mayrovitz Harvey N
机构信息
Internal Medicine, Nova Southeastern University Dr. Kiran C. Patel College of Osteopathic Medicine, Davie, USA.
Medical Education, Nova Southeastern University Dr. Kiran C. Patel College of Allopathic Medicine, Davie, USA.
出版信息
Cureus. 2021 Feb 28;13(2):e13614. doi: 10.7759/cureus.13614.
Background E-cigarette use, or vaping, is known to be associated with potentially life-threatening lung injury, with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reporting 2,807 hospitalizations and 68 deaths in the United States due to e-cigarette or vaping-associated lung injury. Vaping is also a risk factor for and is implicated in the spreading of COVID-19. Despite the consequences of vaping, the views and training of medical students regarding vaping is unclear. This study sought to investigate the knowledge and perception of vaping amongst future health care providers. Methods An anonymous, online survey was administered to 259 first through fourth year medical students at Nova Southeastern University Dr. Kiran C. Patel College of Osteopathic Medicine via a secure website link in October 2019 and January 2020. The survey consisted of two sections. All participants answered section one, involving nine questions. This first section addressed sociodemographic characteristics, personal views on vaping, rating and impact of vaping medical education, and whether students had ever tried vaping. If students had ever vaped, they proceeded to section two of the survey including nine additional questions. Students that reported no past vaping use ended the survey and did not proceed to section two. Section two focused on evaluating vaping habits of users by questioning age of first usage, use frequency and nature, reasons for first trying and/or continuing to use, plans for quitting, personal impact of use, and current use. Data was analyzed with frequency and percentage distributions. Results Most respondents were of age 18-25 years (66.8%) and female (60.2%). Almost all students (96.5%) were aware of the negative health consequences of vaping. More than two thirds of students (68.7%) rated their vaping medical education as inadequate and the majority (76.1%) indicated their medical school curriculum did not impact their view on the matter. Most students (71.0%) reported a more negative stance on vaping due to recent news and media. Of the respondents, over two thirds (37.5%) vaped at least once and were labeled "vapers." The most commonly stated reason for first trying vaping was recreational (60.8%). Half of vapers (50.5%) admitted to vaping in the past year and most vapers (90.6%) did not think their vaping impacted others. Current vaping use was reported in almost one-third of vapers (32.3%) despite knowing its dangers, and several (6.3%) did not consider vaping dangerous. Conclusion The findings from this pilot study conducted at a single medical school indicate possible deficiencies in vaping education, at least as perceived by the respondents and demonstrated by their vaping-related actions. It is unknown if the stated vaping views and practices of these medical students would be positively impacted by better vaping education or if these practices are generalizable to other students. However, the data suggests there is a need to consider more extensive analyses of medical school curriculums with respect to vaping education and training of students in these and related areas. Recommendations to enhance medical school curriculums include vaping-focused respiratory and gastrointestinal lectures, problem-based case studies on vaping, standardized patient encounters, and a community education program taught by medical students.
背景 已知使用电子烟(即吸电子烟)与可能危及生命的肺部损伤有关,美国疾病控制与预防中心报告称,美国有2807人因电子烟或与吸电子烟相关的肺部损伤住院,68人死亡。吸电子烟也是新冠病毒传播的一个风险因素,并与之相关。尽管吸电子烟有这些后果,但医学生对吸电子烟的看法和相关培训情况尚不清楚。本研究旨在调查未来医疗保健提供者对吸电子烟的了解和认知。方法 2019年10月和2020年1月,通过一个安全的网站链接,对诺瓦东南大学基兰·C·帕特尔骨科医学院的259名大一至大四医学生进行了一项匿名在线调查。该调查由两部分组成。所有参与者都回答了第一部分,其中包含9个问题。第一部分涉及社会人口学特征、对吸电子烟的个人看法、吸电子烟医学教育的评分和影响,以及学生是否曾尝试过吸电子烟。如果学生曾吸过电子烟,他们将进入调查的第二部分,其中包含另外9个问题。报告过去没有吸过电子烟的学生结束调查,不进入第二部分。第二部分通过询问首次使用年龄、使用频率和性质、首次尝试和/或继续使用的原因、戒烟计划、使用的个人影响以及当前使用情况,来评估使用者的吸电子烟习惯。数据采用频率和百分比分布进行分析。结果 大多数受访者年龄在18 - 25岁之间(66.8%),女性占60.2%。几乎所有学生(96.5%)都知道吸电子烟对健康有负面影响。超过三分之二的学生(68.7%)认为他们接受的吸电子烟医学教育不足,大多数(76.1%)表示他们的医学院课程没有影响他们对这个问题的看法。大多数学生(71.0%)表示,由于最近的新闻和媒体报道,他们对吸电子烟持更负面的态度。在受访者中,超过三分之二(37.5%)至少吸过一次电子烟,被标记为“电子烟使用者”。首次尝试吸电子烟最常见的原因是出于娱乐目的(60.8%)。一半的电子烟使用者(50.5%)承认在过去一年里吸过电子烟,大多数电子烟使用者(90.6%)认为他们吸电子烟不会影响他人。尽管知道吸电子烟的危害,但近三分之一的电子烟使用者(32.3%)报告目前仍在吸电子烟,还有一些人(6.3%)不认为吸电子烟危险。结论 在一所医学院进行的这项初步研究结果表明,吸电子烟教育可能存在不足,至少从受访者的认知以及他们与吸电子烟相关的行为中可以看出。尚不清楚这些医学生所述的吸电子烟观点和行为是否会因更好的吸电子烟教育而受到积极影响,或者这些行为是否适用于其他学生。然而,数据表明有必要对医学院课程在吸电子烟教育以及在这些和相关领域对学生的培训方面进行更广泛的分析。加强医学院课程的建议包括以吸电子烟为重点的呼吸和胃肠讲座、基于问题的吸电子烟案例研究、标准化病人问诊,以及由医学生讲授的社区教育项目。