1Virology Division, United States Army Medical Research Institute of Infectious Diseases, Frederick, Maryland.
2Darnall Medical Library, Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, Bethesda, Maryland.
Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2021 Apr 26;104(6):2293-2297. doi: 10.4269/ajtmh.21-0216.
Google health-based Knowledge Panels were designed to provide users with high-quality basic medical information on a specific condition. However, any errors contained within Knowledge Panels could result in the widespread distribution of inaccurate health information. We explored the potential for inaccuracies to exist within Google's health-based Knowledge Panels by focusing on a single well-studied pathogen, Ebola virus (EBOV). We then evaluated the accuracy of those transmission modes listed within the Google Ebola Knowledge Panel and investigated the pervasiveness of any misconceptions associated with inaccurate transmission modes among persons living in Africa. We found that the Google Ebola Knowledge Panel inaccurately listed insect bites or stings as modes of EBOV transmission. Our scoping review found 27 articles and reports that revealed that 9 of 11 countries where misconceptions regarding insect transmission of EBOV have been reported are locations of current (i.e., Democratic Republic of Congo and Guinea) or previous EBOV outbreaks. We found reports that up to 26.6% (155/582) of study respondents in Democratic Republic of Congo believed mosquito bite avoidance would prevent EBOV; in other locations of previous large-scale EBOV outbreaks (e.g., Guinea), up to 61.0% (304/498) of respondents believed insects were involved in EBOV transmission. Our findings highlight the potential for errors to exist within the health information contained in Google's health-based Knowledge Panels. Such errors could perpetuate misconceptions or misinformation, leading to mistrust of health workers and aid agencies and in turn undermining public health education or outbreak response efforts.
谷歌基于健康的知识面板旨在为用户提供特定疾病的高质量基本医学信息。然而,知识面板中包含的任何错误都可能导致不准确的健康信息广泛传播。我们通过关注一种研究充分的病原体——埃博拉病毒(EBOV),来研究谷歌基于健康的知识面板中是否存在不准确的可能性。然后,我们评估了谷歌埃博拉知识面板中列出的传播模式的准确性,并调查了生活在非洲的人对不准确传播模式的误解的普遍性。我们发现,谷歌埃博拉知识面板错误地将昆虫叮咬或刺伤列为 EBOV 的传播模式。我们的范围综述发现了 27 篇文章和报告,这些文章和报告表明,11 个报告对昆虫传播 EBOV 存在误解的国家中有 9 个是当前(即刚果民主共和国和几内亚)或以前埃博拉病毒爆发的地点。我们发现报告称,在刚果民主共和国,多达 26.6%(155/582)的研究对象认为避免蚊虫叮咬会预防 EBOV;在以前大规模埃博拉病毒爆发的其他地点(例如,几内亚),多达 61.0%(304/498)的受访者认为昆虫参与了 EBOV 的传播。我们的研究结果强调了谷歌基于健康的知识面板中健康信息可能存在错误的可能性。这些错误可能会使误解或错误信息持续存在,从而导致对卫生工作者和援助机构的不信任,进而破坏公共卫生教育或疫情应对工作。