Department of Biology, California State University, Stanislaus, CA, USA.
Accord Alliance, Higley, AZ, USA.
Endocrine. 2021 Sep;73(3):723-733. doi: 10.1007/s12020-021-02748-4. Epub 2021 May 21.
To define, benchmark, and publicize elements of quality care (i.e., "good practices") for pediatric patients with disorders/differences of sex development (DSD).
Principles of quality care were identified by literature review; consensus exists for 11 good practices and adherence was evaluated through online survey of 21 North American clinical sites.
Strong uptake was observed for many practices, particularly specialty participation (n ≥ 17 of 21 sites for most core specialties); point of contact (n = 18); expertise in gender dysphoria/dissatisfaction (n = 20); and DSD-specific continuing medical education (n = 18). Greater variability was apparent for frequency of peer support referrals (n = 12 universally practiced); standardized questionnaires for routine assessment of psychosocial adaptation (n = 13) and gender development (n = 10); consistently clarifying patient/family values in decision-making (n = 15); genital exam protocols that exclude trainee education as primary reason (n = 15); and internal patient-tracking efforts (n = 5-10 of 20 sites).
This study employed a novel approach to designate DSD good practices and identified areas of consistency and variation in these DSD clinical practices. Good practice benchmarking facilitates quality assessment within and across sites, promotes continuous improvement, and empowers stakeholders in locating and delivering high quality care.
定义、基准测试和宣传儿科性别发育障碍(DSD)患者优质护理的要素(即“良好实践”)。
通过文献回顾确定了优质护理的原则,对于 11 项良好实践达成了共识,并通过对 21 个北美临床站点的在线调查评估了其实施情况。
许多实践得到了广泛采用,特别是专业参与(大多数核心专业中 21 个站点中有 17 个以上);联系点(n=18);性别焦虑/不满方面的专业知识(n=20);以及 DSD 特定的继续医学教育(n=18)。对于同行支持推荐的频率(n=12 个普遍实践);用于常规评估心理社会适应(n=13)和性别发展(n=10)的标准化问卷;在决策中始终明确患者/家庭价值观(n=15);排除培训生教育为主要原因的生殖器检查方案(n=15);以及内部患者跟踪工作(n=20 个站点中的 5-10 个),则存在更大的差异。
本研究采用了一种新颖的方法来指定 DSD 良好实践,并确定了这些 DSD 临床实践中一致性和差异性的领域。良好实践基准测试有助于在站点内和站点间进行质量评估,促进持续改进,并使利益相关者能够定位和提供高质量的护理。