Abrams J, Pearl P, Moody M, Schimpff S C
Department of Medicine, University of Maryland Cancer Center, Baltimore 21201.
Am J Clin Oncol. 1988 Aug;11(4):456-60.
A previous retrospective study of epithelioid granulomas discovered in the liver or spleen at staging laparotomy for Hodgkin's disease showed that the granulomas were not indicative of malignant involvement of these organs. Rather, they correlated with improved relapse-free survival in affected patients compared to those without granulomas. These findings were based on 2 year median follow-up. To confirm and expand these findings after additional follow-up, we analyzed the clinical data for 89 of the original cohort of 91 patients who underwent staging laparotomy at our institution between July, 1968 through December, 1972. Neither time to first relapse nor overall survival duration is now significantly different between the granuloma and nongranuloma groups. Of the nongranuloma patients 23/67 (34%) have relapsed versus 3/16 (19%) patients with granulomas (Fisher's exact test p = 0.184). The relapse-free survival advantage for patients with granulomas seen in the earlier report is no longer apparent after more prolonged follow-up.
先前一项针对霍奇金病分期剖腹术时在肝脏或脾脏发现的上皮样肉芽肿的回顾性研究表明,这些肉芽肿并不提示这些器官存在恶性受累。相反,与没有肉芽肿的患者相比,受影响患者的无复发生存期得到改善与肉芽肿相关。这些发现基于2年的中位随访。为了在额外随访后证实并扩展这些发现,我们分析了1968年7月至1972年12月在我们机构接受分期剖腹术的91例患者原始队列中89例患者的临床数据。肉芽肿组和非肉芽肿组的首次复发时间和总生存时间现在均无显著差异。非肉芽肿患者中有23/67(34%)复发,而肉芽肿患者中有3/16(19%)复发(Fisher精确检验p = 0.184)。经过更长时间的随访后,早期报告中所见的肉芽肿患者的无复发生存优势不再明显。