Chaaya Monique, Ghandour Lilian A, Fouad Fouad M, Germani Aline, Charide Rana, Shahin Yousef, Ismail Suha, Fahd Saleh
Department of Epidemiology and Population Healthxs, Faculty of Health Sciences, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Department of Epidemiology and Population Healthxs, Faculty of Health Sciences, American University of Beirut, Beirut, Lebanon.
Lancet. 2021 Jul;398 Suppl 1:S22. doi: 10.1016/S0140-6736(21)01508-7.
As of Feb 14, 2014, UNRWA had registered almost 53 000 Palestinian refugees from Syria (PRS) who had fled to Lebanon as the result of the conflict in Syria. Half of the PRS had gone to one of the 12 Palestinian camps, which are overcrowded and of poor infrastructure. Consequently, there is concern for the wellbeing of PRS; in particular, their health status and access to medical care. Little attention has been given to non-communicable diseases (NCDs) in the acute phases of emergencies. Therefore, an assessment of the prevalence of NCDs among PRS, as well as the patterns of use of available health care services by PRS, is warranted.
A cross-sectional study was conducted in April, 2018, with 1100 PRS residing inside and outside refugee camps across all governorates of Lebanon. A listing of all PRS families was the sampling frame. A random sample of families was selected and contacted, and then one adult randomly selected from each family was approached for data collection. Pregnant women and participants who were too ill to participate were excluded. After obtaining informed verbal consent, we did face-to-face interviews to collect data on household details (such as type of settlement, source of income) and sociodemographic information, major NCDs (for the household representative), lifestyle behaviours, and health-care use. We invited all participants to UNRWA clinics for physical and biochemical measurements. The study protocol was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the American University of Beirut.
We surveyed 959 PRS (59% male [465], 82% married [785], mean age 43 years [SD 12]). A quarter of those interviewed had at least one NCD; the most prevalent were hypertension (23%; 221 of 959), rheumatic diseases (17%; 166), cardiovascular diseases (CVDs, 13%; 126), diabetes (13%; 124), and chronic respiratory diseases (CRDs) (10%; 100). All these NCDs were more prevalent among PRS inside camps than in those residing outside camps, except for diabetes. Most participants who had been diagnosed with NCDs were adhering to their prescribed medications (90-98%). However, of those reporting CVDs, only 56% (71 of 126) had attended at least one follow-up appointment, and of those reporting rheumatic diseases, only 33% (55 of 166) had attended at least one follow-up appointment. About half of participants reported that they checked their blood pressure (55%; 528 of 959) or blood glucose (45%; 430). 111 of 221 (50%) participants with hypertension monitored their blood pressure, and 78 of 124 (63%) participants with diabetes monitored their blood glucose. 133 participants attended UNRWA clinics for measurements; 40% (54) had obesity (>30 kg/cm), 10% (13) had elevated blood pressure, 12% (16) had stage 1 hypertension, and 8% (10) had stage 2 hypertension. Most participants had normal glucose (67%; 89 of 133), cholesterol (65%; 87), triglyceride (58%; 77), and glycosylated haemoglobin levels (64; 85). A substantial proportion of participants who were tested had undiagnosed diabetes (14%; 33 of 108 reporting no diabetes), undiagnosed hypertension (23%; 19 of 81), uncontrolled diabetes (79% of participants with diabetes; 19 of 24), or uncontrolled hypertension (64% of participants with hypertension; 29 of 45).
Further study is needed to understand why the prevalence of NCDs among PRS residing in Palestinian camps is higher than among those living outside, and to understand whether and why access to medicines is a problem, particularly outside camps. The burden of NCDs among PRS is high and their access to services is not optimal; therefore UNRWA should pay special attention to NCD services in this population. UNRWA should invest in efforts to increase awareness of free blood pressure and blood glucose monitoring services in its clinics, and could actively offer free testing in public areas inside camps. Doctors at UNRWA clinics should recommend that patients monitor their disease more frequently and educate them on how to do so. A limitation of the study was the low percentage of participants who attended UNRWA clinics for physical and biochemical measurements.
UNRWA.
截至2014年2月14日,近东救济工程处已登记了近53000名来自叙利亚的巴勒斯坦难民,他们因叙利亚冲突逃至黎巴嫩。这些难民中有一半前往了12个巴勒斯坦难民营之一,这些难民营人满为患且基础设施差。因此,人们担心这些难民的福祉,尤其是他们的健康状况和获得医疗服务的情况。在紧急情况的急性期,非传染性疾病很少受到关注。因此,有必要评估巴勒斯坦难民中慢性病的患病率以及他们使用现有医疗服务的模式。
2018年4月开展了一项横断面研究,研究对象为居住在黎巴嫩所有省份难民营内外的1100名巴勒斯坦难民。所有巴勒斯坦难民家庭名单作为抽样框架。随机抽取一些家庭并进行联系,然后从每个家庭中随机选取一名成年人进行数据收集。孕妇和病情过重无法参与的参与者被排除在外。在获得口头知情同意后,我们进行了面对面访谈,以收集家庭详细信息(如定居类型、收入来源)和社会人口学信息、主要慢性病(针对家庭代表)、生活方式行为以及医疗保健使用情况的数据。我们邀请所有参与者到近东救济工程处的诊所进行身体检查和生化检测。该研究方案得到了贝鲁特美国大学机构审查委员会的批准。
我们调查了959名巴勒斯坦难民(男性占59%[465人],已婚者占82%[785人],平均年龄43岁[标准差12])。四分之一的受访者至少患有一种慢性病;最常见的是高血压(23%;959人中的221人)、风湿性疾病(17%;166人)、心血管疾病(13%;126人)、糖尿病(13%;124人)和慢性呼吸道疾病(10%;100人)。除糖尿病外,所有这些慢性病在难民营内的巴勒斯坦难民中比在难民营外的难民中更为普遍。大多数被诊断患有慢性病的参与者都坚持按规定服药(90 - 98%)。然而,在报告患有心血管疾病的人中,只有56%(126人中的71人)至少参加过一次随访预约,在报告患有风湿性疾病的人中,只有33%(166人中的55人)至少参加过一次随访预约。约一半的参与者报告他们会测量血压(55%;959人中的528人)或血糖(45%;430人)。221名高血压患者中有111人(50%)监测自己的血压,124名糖尿病患者中有78人(63%)监测自己的血糖。133名参与者到近东救济工程处诊所进行检测;40%(54人)患有肥胖症(体重指数>30kg/m²),10%(13人)血压升高,12%(16人)为1级高血压,8%(10人)为2级高血压。大多数参与者的血糖(67%;133人中的89人)、胆固醇(65%;87人)、甘油三酯(58%;77人)和糖化血红蛋白水平正常(64人;85人)。接受检测的参与者中有很大一部分患有未被诊断出的糖尿病(14%;在报告无糖尿病的108人中的33人)、未被诊断出的高血压(23%;81人中的19人)、未得到控制的糖尿病(糖尿病患者中的79%;24人中的19人)或未得到控制的高血压(高血压患者中的64%;45人中的29人)。
需要进一步研究以了解为何居住在巴勒斯坦难民营中的巴勒斯坦难民慢性病患病率高于居住在难民营外的难民,以及了解获取药品是否存在问题,特别是在难民营外。巴勒斯坦难民中的慢性病负担很高,他们获得服务的情况并不理想;因此,近东救济工程处应特别关注这一人群的慢性病服务。近东救济工程处应努力提高其诊所对免费血压和血糖监测服务的认知度,并可在难民营内的公共场所积极提供免费检测。近东救济工程处诊所的医生应建议患者更频繁地监测病情,并对他们进行如何监测的教育。该研究的一个局限性是到近东救济工程处诊所进行身体检查和生化检测的参与者比例较低。
近东救济工程处。