Rothe A J, Young J W, Keramati B
Department of Diagnostic Radiology, University of Maryland Medical System/Hospital, Baltimore 21201.
Invest Radiol. 1987 Oct;22(10):786-91. doi: 10.1097/00004424-198710000-00004.
Four hundred thirty-five consecutive barium studies of the gastrointestinal tract were examined to determine the efficacy and effectiveness of routinely giving intravenous (IV) glucagon in these studies. Administration of glucagon was randomized. Two staff radiologists evaluated the examinations to determine whether they were of diagnostic quality and rated them on a scale of 1 to 3. Patient response to the injection was monitored. Diagnostic quality of the examinations with and without IV glucagon did not differ significantly, and patient response to the injection was unfavorable. It is concluded that with the additional cost of glucagon, and the lack of demonstrable benefit, routine administration of glucagon is not warranted.
对连续435例胃肠道钡剂造影检查进行了分析,以确定在这些检查中常规静脉注射胰高血糖素的有效性和效果。胰高血糖素的给药是随机的。两名放射科医生对检查进行评估,以确定其是否具有诊断质量,并按1至3级进行评分。监测患者对注射的反应。使用和不使用静脉注射胰高血糖素的检查的诊断质量没有显著差异,并且患者对注射的反应不佳。结论是,由于胰高血糖素增加了成本且未显示出明显益处,因此不建议常规使用胰高血糖素。