Agricultural Engineering Department, Technical University of Cartagena, Paseo Alfonso XIII 48, 30203, Cartagena, Spain.
Agricultural Engineering Department, Technical University of Cartagena, Paseo Alfonso XIII 48, 30203, Cartagena, Spain.
J Environ Manage. 2021 Nov 1;297:113326. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2021.113326. Epub 2021 Jul 26.
Greenhouse cultivation in the Mediterranean region has undoubtedly enhanced the economic growth and has generated social benefits by making an efficient use of resources. However, these production systems caused undesirable environmental impacts. In order to move towards cleaner production in greenhouse areas, this study has assessed the potential environmental benefits and trade-offs of the integration of an on-farm reverse osmosis system powered by photovoltaic solar energy to recycle the drainage effluents from greenhouses. To that end, we compare the environmental footprint of a greenhouse tomato crop using this technology in a hydroponic system (HS), versus the conventional sanded soil 'enarenado' (CS) with free-drainage to soil. Additionally, for comparison, three independent irrigation sources (desalinated seawater with low electrical conductivity and two different mixes of underground and desalinated water, with moderate and high electrical conductivity, respectively) were evaluated. The use of desalinated seawater can help reduce the overexploitation of aquifers, although if the desalination process is not done with clean energy it also comes with a negative impact on the carbon footprint. Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) was used to analyse and evaluate six environmental impact indicators associated with these production systems and water treatments. In addition, a sensitivity analysis was conducted to explore the potential environmental benefits of increasing the use of renewable energy for desalinated water production, whilst also curbing the common over-fertilisation malpractice reported in the study area. Based on our findings, the HS with leachate treatment technology showed, compared to the CS system, a significant reduction in the eutrophication (72 %), although it did inevitably increase the depletion of fossil fuels (43 %) global warming (37 %) and acidification (32 %) impacts, due to the need for additional infrastructure and equipment. Among the inputs considered for the cultivation systems, the greenhouse structure, and the production of fertilisers and electricity for fertigation represented the highest environmental burdens. When comparing the three irrigation treatments, it was observed that the partial substitution of desalinated seawater by brackish groundwater substantially mitigated (27 %) the global warming footprint. The sensitivity analysis revealed that a significant reduction in the environmental impact is feasible.
地中海地区的温室种植无疑促进了经济增长,并通过有效利用资源带来了社会效益。然而,这些生产系统造成了不良的环境影响。为了在温室地区实现更清洁的生产,本研究评估了在温室中整合利用光伏太阳能驱动的农场反渗透系统来回收温室排水的潜在环境效益和权衡取舍。为此,我们将使用这项技术的水培系统(HS)中的温室番茄作物的环境足迹与传统的沙质土壤 'enarenado'(CS)(具有自由排水到土壤的功能)进行了比较。此外,为了进行比较,还评估了三种独立的灌溉水源(电导率较低的淡化海水以及电导率分别适中、较高的两种地下和淡化水的混合水)。使用淡化海水可以帮助减少对含水层的过度开采,尽管如果淡化过程不是使用清洁能源进行,也会对碳足迹产生负面影响。生命周期评估(LCA)用于分析和评估与这些生产系统和水疗相关的六个环境影响指标。此外,还进行了敏感性分析,以探讨增加可再生能源用于淡化海水生产的潜在环境效益,同时遏制研究地区常见的过度施肥做法。根据我们的研究结果,与 CS 系统相比,具有渗滤液处理技术的 HS 系统在富营养化方面显著减少了(72%),尽管由于需要额外的基础设施和设备,它不可避免地增加了化石燃料的枯竭(43%)、全球变暖(37%)和酸化(32%)的影响。在所考虑的栽培系统的投入中,温室结构以及肥料的生产和施肥用电代表了最高的环境负担。在比较三种灌溉处理时,观察到部分替代淡化海水的咸地下水可大大减轻(27%)全球变暖足迹。敏感性分析表明,降低环境影响是可行的。