College of Medical and Dental Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Uyo, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria.
Int J Pharm Pract. 2021 Oct 18;29(5):471-479. doi: 10.1093/ijpp/riab046.
Studies show that clinical pharmacy services are effective in optimizing medicines use and patients' outcomes. This study aimed to determine the clinical pharmacy services provided in public sector hospitals in Nigeria.
This was an online survey of 296 primary, secondary and tertiary care hospitals sampled purposively across the 36 States and Federal Capital Territory in Nigeria. Data analysis was conducted descriptively via χ 2 test and multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA).
Responses were obtained from 272 hospitals in the country with a survey completion rate of 88%. This included 55 tertiary, 72 secondary and 145 primary healthcare centres (PHCs). Pharmacists provided pharmaceutical care services in all the tertiary care hospitals, 94% of the secondary and in only 6% of the PHCs surveyed. Most of the secondary and tertiary care hospitals provided medicines information, patient education and counselling, and in-patient dispensing services [n = 97 (79%), 116 (94%), 88 (72%)], respectively. However, fewer than a third reported involvement in multidisciplinary ward rounds, medication chart review and antibiotic stewardship programmes [n = 18 (15%), 33 (27%), 22 (18%), respectively]. Furthermore, medication error reporting and pharmacovigilance services were each routinely provided in only about half of the secondary and tertiary care hospitals [n = 62 (50%)], and this was not associated with the level of care (P > 0.05).
The findings of this study demonstrate disparity in clinical pharmacy service availability across the various levels of care in Nigeria and emphasize the need to prioritize their integration within the primary care sector.
研究表明,临床药学服务可有效优化药物使用和患者结局。本研究旨在确定尼日利亚公立医疗机构提供的临床药学服务。
这是一项针对尼日利亚 36 个州和联邦首都区 296 家初级、二级和三级保健医院的在线调查。数据分析采用 χ²检验和多变量方差分析(MANOVA)进行描述性分析。
该国共有 272 家医院做出回应,调查完成率为 88%。其中包括 55 家三级医院、72 家二级医院和 145 家初级保健中心(PHC)。药剂师在所有三级保健医院、94%的二级医院和仅 6%的 PHC 提供药学保健服务。大多数二级和三级保健医院提供药品信息、患者教育和咨询以及住院配药服务[n=97(79%)、116(94%)、88(72%)]。然而,不到三分之一的医院报告参与多学科病房查房、药物图表审查和抗生素管理计划[n=18(15%)、33(27%)、22(18%)]。此外,只有大约一半的二级和三级保健医院[分别为 n=62(50%)]定期提供药物错误报告和药物警戒服务,这与护理水平无关(P>0.05)。
本研究的发现表明,尼日利亚不同护理级别的临床药学服务提供存在差异,并强调需要优先将其纳入初级保健部门。