Nagoya University Graduate School of Medicine, Nagoya, Japan.
Department of Patient Safety, Nagoya University Hospital, Nagoya, Japan.
Nagoya J Med Sci. 2021 Aug;83(3):397-405. doi: 10.18999/nagjms.83.3.397.
Medical safety management has an economic dimension that has received little attention. Medical expenses associated with medical malpractice in Japan should be investigated in relation to patient safety measures and their consequences. We analyzed medical accidents that occurred within the past seven years at a university hospital. We determined that 197 accidents involved negligence by the hospital in the years from 2011 to 2017, for which the institution bore the costs of the resulting treatment; those expenses totaled JPY 30.547 million. Most incidents occurred in the hospital ward (82, 41.6%); those in the operating room were the most expensive (JPY 19.493 million, 63.8%). The greatest number of cases involved drug administration (63, 32.0%). Materials inadvertently left in surgical sites ("remnants") cost the hospital the most per incident (JPY 9.767 million, 32.0%). Of these, medical treatment costs for remnants associated with vascular invasion were the highest. Although the total number of malpractice incidents increased over time, the annual cost to the hospital decreased, especially in cases in which costs exceeded JPY 100,000, and those associated with the operating room. Our results suggested that adverse events must be addressed to foster patient safety, decrease medical expenses, and improve hospital administrative capacity.
医疗安全管理具有经济维度,但这一点一直未受到太多关注。日本的医疗事故相关费用应该与患者安全措施及其后果联系起来进行调查。我们分析了过去 7 年在一所大学附属医院发生的医疗事故。我们发现,2011 年至 2017 年期间,医院有 197 起事故是由于疏忽造成的,机构承担了由此产生的治疗费用;这些费用总计 3054.7 万日元。大多数事故发生在医院病房(82 起,占 41.6%);手术室的事故最为昂贵(1949.3 万日元,占 63.8%)。涉及药物管理的案例最多(63 起,占 32.0%)。手术部位遗留的材料(“残留物”)给医院带来的每起事件损失最大(976.7 万日元,占 32.0%)。在这些案例中,与血管入侵相关的残留物的医疗费用最高。尽管医疗事故的总数量随着时间的推移而增加,但医院的年度成本却有所下降,尤其是在费用超过 10 万日元和与手术室相关的案例中。我们的结果表明,必须解决不良事件,以促进患者安全、降低医疗费用并提高医院管理能力。