Gallop Katy, Lloyd Andrew J, Olt Jennifer, Marshall Jade
Acaster Lloyd Consulting Ltd, Lacon House, 84 Theobald's Road, London WC1X 8NL, United Kingdom.
Acaster Lloyd Consulting Ltd, Lacon House, 84 Theobald's Road, London WC1X 8NL, United Kingdom.
Epilepsy Behav. 2021 Oct 1;124:108324. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2021.108324.
Developmental and epileptic encephalopathies (DEEs) are rare neurodevelopmental disorders characterized by early-onset seizures and numerous comorbidities. Due to the complex requirements for the care of a child with a DEE, these disorders would be expected to impact health-related quality of life (HRQL) for caregivers as well as for patients. The objective of this literature review was to describe the impact of DEEs on the HRQL, emotional wellbeing, and usual activities (social, work, relationships, etc.) of caregivers, including the wider impact on other family members such as siblings.
A literature search was conducted in May 2020 using MEDLINE® and Embase® databases. Quantitative and qualitative studies were identified using search terms related to family, disease type (including >20 specific DEEs), and quality of life/methodology. Each study was assessed for relevance and was graded using customized critical appraisal criteria. Findings from studies that were given the highest quality ratings were summarized and used to develop a conceptual model to illustrate the complex impact of DEEs on caregiver HRQL.
Sixty-seven relevant studies were identified, of which 39 (27 quantitative, 12 qualitative) met the highest appraisal criteria. The studies recruited caregivers of patients with one of eight individual DEEs, or pediatric intractable or refractory epilepsy. Most studies reported negative impacts on HRQL and emotional wellbeing in caregivers. The wide-ranging impact of a DEE was highlighted by reports of negative effects on caregivers' physical health, daily activities, relationships, social activities, leisure time, work, and productivity. Factors that influenced the perceived impact included demographic characteristics (e.g., child's age, living arrangements, family income) and clinical factors (e.g., feeding or sleep difficulties, disease severity). Few studies evaluated the impact on siblings.
There is evidence that DEEs can impact HRQL and emotional wellbeing and can limit usual activities for the primary caregiver and their wider family. However, no research was identified regarding many individual DEEs, and only limited research assessed the impact on different family members with most studies focusing on mothers. Further research is required to understand the influence of certain factors such as the age of the patient, disease severity, and seizures on caregiver burden. Furthermore, the review highlighted the lack of appropriate measurement tools to assess caregiver HRQL in this population.
发育性和癫痫性脑病(DEEs)是罕见的神经发育障碍,其特征为早发性癫痫发作和众多合并症。由于护理患有DEE的儿童有复杂的要求,预计这些疾病会对照顾者以及患者的健康相关生活质量(HRQL)产生影响。这篇文献综述的目的是描述DEEs对照顾者的HRQL、情绪健康和日常活动(社交、工作、人际关系等)的影响,包括对其他家庭成员如兄弟姐妹的更广泛影响。
2020年5月使用MEDLINE®和Embase®数据库进行文献检索。使用与家庭、疾病类型(包括20多种特定的DEEs)和生活质量/方法相关的检索词来识别定量和定性研究。对每项研究进行相关性评估,并使用定制的批判性评价标准进行评分。对质量评级最高的研究结果进行总结,并用于构建一个概念模型,以说明DEEs对照顾者HRQL的复杂影响。
共识别出67项相关研究,其中39项(27项定量研究,12项定性研究)符合最高评价标准。这些研究招募了患有八种个体DEEs之一的患者或小儿难治性癫痫患者的照顾者。大多数研究报告了对照顾者HRQL和情绪健康的负面影响。对照顾者身体健康、日常活动、人际关系、社交活动、休闲时间、工作和生产力的负面影响报告突出了DEEs的广泛影响。影响感知影响的因素包括人口统计学特征(如孩子的年龄、居住安排、家庭收入)和临床因素(如喂养或睡眠困难、疾病严重程度)。很少有研究评估对兄弟姐妹的影响。
有证据表明,DEEs会影响HRQL和情绪健康,并会限制主要照顾者及其更广泛家庭的日常活动。然而,关于许多个体DEEs尚未发现相关研究,只有有限的研究评估了对不同家庭成员的影响,大多数研究集中在母亲身上。需要进一步研究以了解某些因素,如患者年龄、疾病严重程度和癫痫发作对照顾者负担的影响。此外,综述强调缺乏适当的测量工具来评估该人群中照顾者 的HRQL。