Ishida Mami, Matsuzaki Keiichi, Ikai Hiroshi, Suzuki Hitoshi, Kawamura Takashi, Suzuki Yusuke
Department of Preventive Services, Kyoto University School of Public Health, Kyoto, Japan.
Kyoto University Health Service, Kyoto, Japan.
Value Health Reg Issues. 2022 May;29:8-15. doi: 10.1016/j.vhri.2021.07.011. Epub 2021 Nov 15.
IgA nephropathy (IgAN) is the most common primary chronic glomerulonephritis and a major cause of end-stage kidney disease worldwide. Novel biomarkers, including the aberrantly glycosylated IgA1 and glycan-specific antibodies, could be useful in the diagnosis of IgAN. The aim of this study was to assess the cost analysis of IgAN screening using novel biomarkers in addition to the conventional screening compared with conventional screening alone.
To estimate the medical expense of each strategy related to renal disease for 40 years, we developed an analytical decision model. The decision tree started at "40 years of age with first-time hematuria." It simulated 2 clinical strategies: IgAN screening using the novel biomarkers (group N) and conventional screening (group C). The analysis results were presented as medical expenses from a societal perspective. Discounting was not conducted.
The expected medical expense per person for 40 years was ¥31.2 million ($291 000) in group N and ¥33.4 million ($312 000) in group C; hence, expense in group N was lower by ¥2.2 million (~$21 000). In group N, the expected value of IgAN increased by 5.67% points (N 48.44%, C 42.77%) and that of dialysis introduction decreased by 0.85% points (N 19.06%, C 19.91%). In the sensitivity analysis, expenses could be reduced in almost all cases except when renal biopsy using conventional screening was performed at the rate of 73% or higher.
Screening for IgAN using novel biomarkers would reduce renal disease-related expenses.
IgA肾病(IgAN)是全球最常见的原发性慢性肾小球肾炎,也是终末期肾病的主要病因。包括异常糖基化IgA1和聚糖特异性抗体在内的新型生物标志物可能有助于IgAN的诊断。本研究旨在评估除传统筛查外,使用新型生物标志物进行IgA肾病筛查与单独使用传统筛查相比的成本分析。
为了估计40年中每种与肾病相关策略的医疗费用,我们开发了一个分析决策模型。决策树从“40岁首次出现血尿”开始。它模拟了2种临床策略:使用新型生物标志物进行IgA肾病筛查(N组)和传统筛查(C组)。分析结果从社会角度以医疗费用呈现。未进行贴现。
N组40年人均预期医疗费用为3120万元(约29.1万美元),C组为3340万元(约31.2万美元);因此,N组费用低220万元(约2.1万美元)。在N组中,IgA肾病的预期发生率增加了5.67个百分点(N组48.44%,C组42.77%),透析开始率降低了0.85个百分点(N组19.06%,C组19.91%)。在敏感性分析中,除了传统筛查肾活检率达到73%或更高的情况外,几乎在所有情况下费用都可以降低。
使用新型生物标志物筛查IgA肾病可降低与肾病相关的费用。