Kelly Laura, Sankaranarayanan Sailesh
Paediatrics, Birmingham Women's and Children's NHS Foundation Trust, Birmingham, Birmingham, UK
Postgraduate Medical and Dental Education, Health Education England West Midlands, Edgbaston, Birmingham, UK.
Arch Dis Child Educ Pract Ed. 2023 Feb;108(1):54-57. doi: 10.1136/archdischild-2020-321066. Epub 2021 Dec 2.
Differential attainment is the gap in attainment between different demographic groups undertaking the same assessment. Across the UK, we see differences in outcome in undergraduate and postgraduate medical education on the basis of gender, age, ethnicity and country of primary medical qualification which cannot be explained by a difference in ability. The largest gaps appear when we look at the variation in outcome between UK and international medical graduates (IMGs) and between white British and black, Asian and minority ethnic (BAME) doctors in postgraduate medical education. If we look to postgraduate medical examinations, the differences in attainment are stark and occur across all medical specialties, with paediatrics being no exception. The differences are also seen in the rates of relative success in recruitment to training posts and in a trainee's likelihood of getting a satisfactory outcome at the Annual Review of Competence Progression. Ensuring all doctors reach their full potential is undoubtedly an issue of fairness that is of particular significance to paediatrics as IMGs make up 47% of our medical workforce and 36% of the paediatric workforce identifies as being from a BAME group. It is clear that if we fail to close the gap in differential attainment, there will be both a personal cost to affected individuals, but also a cost to the wider paediatric profession and the children they serve. This paper hopes to summarise the background and causes to differential attainment and look towards possible interventions that might tackle this issue.
差异成就指的是参加相同评估的不同人口群体在成就方面的差距。在英国,我们发现本科和研究生医学教育在性别、年龄、种族以及初始医学资格所属国家等方面存在结果差异,而这些差异无法用能力差异来解释。当我们审视英国医学毕业生和国际医学毕业生(IMGs)之间以及英国白人医生与黑人、亚洲及少数族裔(BAME)医生在研究生医学教育中的结果差异时,差距最为明显。若以研究生医学考试来看,成就差异十分显著,且在所有医学专业中都存在,儿科也不例外。在培训岗位招聘的相对成功率以及学员在能力进展年度评估中获得满意结果的可能性方面也存在差异。确保所有医生充分发挥潜力无疑是一个公平问题,对儿科尤为重要,因为国际医学毕业生占我们医学劳动力的47%,且36%的儿科劳动力属于少数族裔群体。显然,如果我们未能缩小差异成就方面的差距,不仅会给受影响的个人带来个人代价,也会给更广泛的儿科行业及其服务的儿童带来代价。本文希望总结差异成就的背景和成因,并探讨可能解决这一问题的干预措施。