Karimi Fatemeh, Niu Jiansheng, Gouweleeuw Kim, Almeida Quincy, Jiang Ning
Systems Design Engineering Department, University of Waterloo, Waterloo N2L 3G1, Canada.
Department of Human Media Interaction, University of Twente, 7522 NB Enschede, The Netherlands.
Brain Commun. 2021 Nov 24;3(4):fcab277. doi: 10.1093/braincomms/fcab277. eCollection 2021.
Freezing of gait is the most severe gait deficit associated with Parkinson's disease and significantly affects patients' independence and consequently their quality of life. The lack of a clear understanding of its underlying neurophysiological mechanism has resulted in limited effectiveness of the current treatment options. In this study, we investigated EEG features over (pre-)supplementary motor area and primary motor cortex during a simple cue-based ankle dorsiflexion movement. These features include movement-related cortical potentials (0.05-5 Hz) and brain oscillations (1-50 Hz). Electromyogram signal from the tibialis anterior muscle of the dominant foot was used to determine the movement onset. The EEG features before, during and following the onset of the movement were compared among three groups of participants: patients with freezing ( = 14, 11 males), patients without freezing ( = 14, 13 males) and healthy age-matched controls ( = 13, 10 males) with 15 recorded trials for each individual. Additionally, Parkinson's disease patients with freezing of gait were separated into mild ( = 7) and severe cases ( = 5), so that EEG features associated with freezing severity could be investigated. The results indicated significant differences between patients with severe freezing of gait compared to healthy controls and patients without freezing of gait. In addition, patients with mild and severe freezing represented cortical activity differences. For patients with freezing, the initial component of movement-related cortical potential is significantly lower than that of the healthy controls ( = 0.002) and is affected by the severity of freezing. Furthermore, a striking absence of beta frequency band (12-35 Hz) desynchronization was observed in patients with freezing, especially low-beta frequency band over Cz, before the movement, which was also associated with the severity of the freezing of gait. Low-beta (13-20 Hz) and high-beta (21-35 Hz) frequency band activities represented unique features for each group. Beta event-related desynchronization over Cz present in healthy controls prior to movement onset, was partially replaced by the theta band (4-8 Hz) synchrony in patients with freezing. Patients with severe freezing also represented some level of theta band synchronization over contralateral supplementary motor area. This suggests the involvement of cognitive processing over the motor cortex in controlling cue-based voluntary movement as a compensatory mechanism associated with freezing of gait. The EEG features identified in this study are indicative of important freezing of gait clinical characteristics such as severity and contribute to a better understanding of the underlying neurophysiology of the mysterious phenomenon of freezing of gait.
冻结步态是与帕金森病相关的最严重的步态缺陷,严重影响患者的独立性,进而影响其生活质量。由于对其潜在神经生理机制缺乏清晰的认识,导致目前的治疗方案效果有限。在本研究中,我们调查了在基于简单提示的踝关节背屈运动过程中,(前)辅助运动区和初级运动皮层的脑电图特征。这些特征包括运动相关皮层电位(0.05 - 5赫兹)和脑振荡(1 - 50赫兹)。来自优势脚胫骨前肌的肌电图信号用于确定运动起始。在三组参与者中比较了运动起始前、运动过程中和运动后的脑电图特征:冻结步态患者(n = 14,男性11名)、无冻结步态患者(n = 14,男性13名)和年龄匹配的健康对照组(n = 13,男性10名),每人记录15次试验。此外,将冻结步态的帕金森病患者分为轻度(n = 7)和重度病例(n = 5),以便研究与冻结严重程度相关的脑电图特征。结果表明,与健康对照组和无冻结步态的患者相比,重度冻结步态患者存在显著差异。此外,轻度和重度冻结患者表现出皮层活动差异。对于冻结步态患者,运动相关皮层电位的初始成分显著低于健康对照组(p = 0.002),且受冻结严重程度影响。此外,在冻结步态患者中观察到运动前β频段(12 - 35赫兹)去同步化明显缺失,尤其是 Cz 电极上方的低β频段,这也与冻结步态的严重程度相关。低β(13 - 20赫兹)和高β(21 - 35赫兹)频段活动代表了每组的独特特征。健康对照组在运动起始前 Cz 电极处出现的β事件相关去同步化,在冻结步态患者中部分被θ频段(4 - 8赫兹)同步化所取代。重度冻结患者在对侧辅助运动区也表现出一定程度的θ频段同步化。这表明运动皮层的认知加工参与了基于提示的自主运动控制,作为与冻结步态相关的一种补偿机制。本研究中确定的脑电图特征表明了冻结步态的重要临床特征,如严重程度,有助于更好地理解冻结步态这一神秘现象的潜在神经生理学。