Rozek David C, Baker Shelby N, Rugo Kelsi F, Steigerwald Victoria L, Sippel Lauren M, Holliday Ryan, Roberge Erika M, Held Philip, Mota Natalie, Smith Noelle B
UCF RESTORES and Department of Psychology, University of Central Florida, Orlando, Florida, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah, USA.
J Trauma Stress. 2022 Apr;35(2):729-745. doi: 10.1002/jts.22774. Epub 2021 Dec 31.
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a well-established risk factor for suicidal thoughts and behaviors. Historically, guidelines for treating PTSD have recommended against the use of trauma-focused therapies for patients who are at high risk for suicide, likely due to concerns about potential suicide-related iatrogenesis, specifically the "triggering" of suicidal behaviors. This systematic review examined evidence of the impact of treatments specifically designed to treat PTSD or suicide on both PTSD- and suicide-related outcomes. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines were followed, and a total of 33 articles met the full inclusion criteria: 23 examining PTSD treatments, four examining suicide-focused treatments, and six examining combined treatments. PTSD and combined treatments reduced both PTSD- and suicide-related outcomes, with most studies focusing on cognitive processing therapy or prolonged exposure. Suicide-focused treatments (e.g., cognitive therapies for suicide prevention) also reduced suicide-related outcomes, but the findings were mixed for their impact on PTSD-related outcomes. Overall, PTSD treatments had the most support, primarily due to a larger number of studies examining their outcomes. This supports current clinical guidelines, which suggest utilizing PTSD treatments for individuals who have PTSD and are at risk for suicide. Suicide-focused and combined treatments also appeared to be promising formats, although additional research is needed. Future research should seek to compare the effectiveness of the approaches to the treatment of PTSD and suicidal thoughts and behaviors concurrently as well as to inform guidelines aimed at supporting decisions about the selection of an appropriate treatment approach.
创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)是自杀念头和行为的一个公认风险因素。从历史上看,PTSD治疗指南建议,对于有高自杀风险的患者,不要使用以创伤为重点的疗法,这可能是因为担心潜在的与自杀相关的医源性因素,特别是自杀行为的“触发”。本系统评价考察了专门设计用于治疗PTSD或自杀的疗法对PTSD相关结局和自杀相关结局影响的证据。遵循了系统评价和Meta分析的首选报告项目(PRISMA)指南,共有33篇文章符合完全纳入标准:23篇考察PTSD治疗,4篇考察以自杀为重点的治疗,6篇考察联合治疗。PTSD治疗和联合治疗降低了PTSD相关结局和自杀相关结局,大多数研究集中在认知加工疗法或延长暴露疗法。以自杀为重点的治疗(如预防自杀的认知疗法)也降低了自杀相关结局,但其对PTSD相关结局的影响结果不一。总体而言,PTSD治疗得到的支持最多,主要是因为考察其结局的研究数量较多。这支持了当前的临床指南,即建议对患有PTSD且有自杀风险的个体使用PTSD治疗。以自杀为重点的治疗和联合治疗似乎也是很有前景的治疗形式,不过还需要更多研究。未来的研究应寻求同时比较治疗PTSD以及自杀念头和行为的方法的有效性,并为旨在支持选择合适治疗方法的指南提供信息。