Shi Jian, Fu Shenao, Cavagnaro María José, Xu Shaokang, Zhao Mingyi
Department of Spine Surgery, The Third Xiangya Hospital, Central South University, Changsha, China.
Xiangya School of Medicine, Central South University, Changsha, China.
Front Physiol. 2021 Dec 24;12:726591. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2021.726591. eCollection 2021.
Fractures of complex body parts are often serious and difficult to handle, and they have high technical and training requirements. However, the realistic situation is that there are few opportunities for the junior residents, trainee doctors, and especially medical students to contact enough clinical practice and see such fracture patients. Fortunately, with the rapid development and continuous progress of 3D printing and related technologies, this situation has gradually gotten better and better. In this research, we confirmed that 3D printing technology could improve the effectiveness of fracture teaching and medical learning from multiple dimensions. We comprehensively screened and assessed 223 papers from the Web of Science (WoS) Core Collection on October 3, 2021, with "((3D) AND ((printing) OR (printed)) AND (fracture)) AND ((education) OR (training) OR (teaching))" as the retrieval strategy. Additionally, we used the VOSviewer software to analyze the keywords and countries and the organizations of the publications, then a series of scientometric and visualized analyses were made based on the retrieval results. Afterward, multiple databases were retrieved according to our selection criteria, we selected eight studies for the extensive literature analysis. The extracted data contained information of authors, problems solved, participants, methods, assessments, results, and benefits/limitations. These intuitive and in-depth analyses further confirmed and appraised the advantages of 3D printing in complex fracture models more objectively. In conclusion, 3D printing could improve the effectiveness and extension of fracture teaching, as well as medical learning, by providing the powerful interaction with 3D effect, wakening students learning interest, and allowing the junior residents, trainee doctors to have as realistic a virtual practice experience as possible. Through this research, it is expected that more researchers could be attracted to conduct more comprehensive and thorough studies on the application of 3D printing for training and educational propose, to promote the development of 3D technology-based medical education practice and further deepen the reform of medical education and improve the quality of fracture education and learning.
复杂身体部位的骨折通常较为严重且处理难度大,对技术和培训要求很高。然而,现实情况是,初级住院医师、实习医生,尤其是医学生很少有机会接触到足够的临床实践并见到此类骨折患者。幸运的是,随着3D打印及相关技术的快速发展和不断进步,这种情况已逐渐改善。在本研究中,我们证实3D打印技术可从多个维度提高骨折教学和医学学习的效果。我们于2021年10月3日在Web of Science(WoS)核心合集中以“((3D) AND ((printing) OR (printed)) AND (fracture)) AND ((education) OR (training) OR (teaching))”作为检索策略,全面筛选和评估了223篇论文。此外,我们使用VOSviewer软件分析关键词、国家和出版物的组织,然后基于检索结果进行了一系列科学计量和可视化分析。之后,根据我们的选择标准检索了多个数据库,我们选择了八项研究进行广泛的文献分析。提取的数据包含作者信息、解决的问题、参与者、方法、评估、结果以及益处/局限性。这些直观而深入的分析进一步更客观地证实和评估了3D打印在复杂骨折模型中的优势。总之,3D打印通过提供具有3D效果的强大互动、激发学生的学习兴趣,并让初级住院医师、实习医生获得尽可能逼真的虚拟实践体验,可提高骨折教学以及医学学习的效果和广度。通过本研究,期望能吸引更多研究人员针对3D打印在培训和教育方面的应用进行更全面、深入的研究,以推动基于3D技术医学教育实践的发展,并进一步深化医学教育改革,提高骨折教育和学习的质量。
BMC Med Educ. 2023-6-22
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015-1
Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg. 2024-2
Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2020-1
Materials (Basel). 2022-7-8
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2025-2
Bioengineering (Basel). 2022-9-14
Front Pharmacol. 2021-8-6
Gigascience. 2020-8-1
Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2018-11-22
Updates Surg. 2018-9
BMJ Simul Technol Enhanc Learn. 2018-1