Wang Mingze, Lin Fa, Qiu Hancheng, Cao Yong, Wang Shuo, Zhao Jizong
Department of Neurosurgery, Beijing Tiantan Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing, China.
China National Clinical Research Center for Neurological Diseases, Beijing, China.
Front Neurol. 2021 Dec 24;12:756307. doi: 10.3389/fneur.2021.756307. eCollection 2021.
It remains a challenge in surgical treatments of brain arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) in Spetzler-Martin Grade (SMG) IV and V to achieve both optimal neurological outcomes and complete obliteration. The authors reported a series of patients with AVMs in SMG IV and V who underwent a surgical paradigm of endovascular embolization and simultaneous microsurgical resection based on the one-staged hybrid operation. Participants in the multicenter prospective clinical trial (NCT03774017) between January 2016 and December 2019 were enrolled. Patients who received endovascular embolization plus microsurgical resection (EE+MRS) and those who received intraoperative digital subtraction angiography plus microsurgical resection (iDSA+MRS) were divided into two groups. Information on clinical features, operative details, and clinical outcomes were extracted from the database. Deterioration of neurological deficits (DNDs) was defined as the primary outcome, which represented neurological outcomes. The time of microsurgical operation and blood loss were defined as the secondary outcomes representing microsurgical risks and difficulties. Outcomes and technical details were compared between groups. Thirty-eight cases (male: female = 23:15) were enrolled, with 24 cases in the EE+MRS group and 14 in the iDSA+MRS group. Five cases (13.2%) were in SMG V and 33 cases (86.8%) were in SMG IV. Fourteen cases (36.8%) underwent the paradigm of microsurgical resection plus intraoperative DSA. Twenty-four cases (63.2%, = 24) underwent the paradigm of endovascular embolization plus simultaneous microsurgical resection. Degradations of SMG were achieved in 15 cases. Of the cases, two cases got the residual nidus detected via intraoperative DSA and resected. Deterioration of neurological deficits occurred in 23.7% of cases ( = 9) when discharged, and in 13.5, 13.5, 8.1% of cases at the follow-ups of 3, 6, and 12 months, respectively, without significant difference between groups ( > 0.05). Intracranial hemorrhagic complications were reported in three cases (7.9%) of the EE+MRS group only. The embolization did not significantly affect the surgical time and intraoperative blood loss. The subtotal embolization or the degradation of size by 2 points resulted in no DNDs. The paradigms based on the one-staged hybrid operation were practical and effective in treating high-grade AVMs. Appropriate intraoperative embolization could help decrease operative risks and difficulties and improve neurological outcomes.
在Spetzler-Martin分级(SMG)IV级和V级脑动静脉畸形(AVM)的外科治疗中,实现最佳神经学预后和完全闭塞仍然是一项挑战。作者报告了一系列SMG IV级和V级AVM患者,他们接受了基于一期杂交手术的血管内栓塞联合显微手术切除的手术模式。纳入了2016年1月至2019年12月期间多中心前瞻性临床试验(NCT03774017)的参与者。接受血管内栓塞加显微手术切除(EE+MRS)的患者和接受术中数字减影血管造影加显微手术切除(iDSA+MRS)的患者被分为两组。从数据库中提取临床特征、手术细节和临床结果的信息。神经功能缺损恶化(DND)被定义为主要结局,代表神经学预后。显微手术时间和失血量被定义为代表显微手术风险和难度的次要结局。比较两组的结局和技术细节。共纳入38例患者(男∶女=23∶15),EE+MRS组24例,iDSA+MRS组14例。5例(13.2%)为SMG V级,33例(86.8%)为SMG IV级。14例(36.8%)患者接受了显微手术切除加术中DSA的模式。24例(63.2%,n=24)患者接受了血管内栓塞联合显微手术切除的模式。15例患者实现了SMG降级。其中,2例患者通过术中DSA检测到残留病灶并进行了切除。出院时23.7%(n=9)的患者出现神经功能缺损恶化,在术后3、6和12个月的随访中,分别有13.5%、13.5%和8.1%的患者出现神经功能缺损恶化,两组之间无显著差异(P>0.05)。仅EE+MRS组有3例(7.9%)患者报告了颅内出血并发症。栓塞对手术时间和术中失血量无显著影响。次全栓塞或体积缩小2级未导致DND。基于一期杂交手术的模式在治疗高级别AVM方面切实有效。适当的术中栓塞有助于降低手术风险和难度,并改善神经学预后。