Clarkson B D, Gee T, Arlin Z A, Mertelsmann R, Kempin S J, Dinsmore R E, O'Reilly R J, Andreeff M, Berman E, Little C
Crit Rev Oncol Hematol. 1986;4(3):221-48. doi: 10.1016/s1040-8428(86)80013-0.
The results of treatment of 629 previously untreated adults with acute leukemia at Memorial Hospital are reviewed. During the past 14 years, 135 adults (greater than 15 years) with acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) have been treated with one of three successive multidrug-intensive treatment protocols (L2, L10/10M, and L17/17M), each calling for 2.5 to 3 years of systemic chemotherapy and prophylactic intrathecal methotrexate without cranial irradiation. The complete remission (CR) rates were L2 (n = 22) = 77%; L10/10M (n = 69) = 86%; L17/17M (n = 44) = 77%. The median durations of survival and remission were, respectively, L2 = 33 and 30 months; L10/10M = 62 months and not reached; and L17/17M = not reached. Almost all relapses occurred within the first 3 years while still continuing treatment, and there were only rate late relapses after stopping treatment. It appears that approximately half of the patients may have been cured with the latest two protocols. During the last 17 years, 494 adults aged 15 to greater than 70 with acute nonlymphoblastic leukemia (ANLL) were treated with one of five successive multiple drug treatment protocols of varying intensity (arabinosylcytosine + 6-thioguanine [n = 36]; L6 [n = 101]; L12 [n = 104]; L14/14M [n = 121]; and L16/16M [n = 132]). Patients with myelodysplastic syndromes generally were not treated until they developed acute leukemia, but were then entered and included in the results. Secondary leukemias following treatment of other neoplastic diseases were not included. The complete remission rates were fairly constant between 47 and 64% and the median durations of remissions were between 9 and 21 months. The intensive treatment L14 and L16 protocols were associated with more early deaths and did not result in a significantly improved remission incidence or duration or survival. With all protocols, the majority of relapses occurred within the first 2 years, but relapses continued to occur at a decreasing rate for 4 years and occasionally even later. Whereas a small fraction (approximately 10 to 15%) of adults with ANLL are now apparently being cured with combination chemotherapy, despite intensive efforts there has been little improvement during the last decade and more selective and effective forms of treatment are urgently needed.
回顾了纪念医院对629例既往未接受治疗的成年急性白血病患者的治疗结果。在过去14年中,135例年龄大于15岁的急性淋巴细胞白血病(ALL)成人患者接受了三种连续多药强化治疗方案(L2、L10/10M和L17/17M)中的一种,每种方案都需要进行2.5至3年的全身化疗以及预防性鞘内注射甲氨蝶呤,无需颅脑照射。完全缓解(CR)率分别为:L2组(n = 22)为77%;L10/10M组(n = 69)为86%;L17/17M组(n = 44)为77%。生存和缓解的中位持续时间分别为:L2组为33个月和30个月;L10/10M组为62个月且未达到;L17/17M组未达到。几乎所有复发都发生在最初3年仍在继续治疗期间,停止治疗后仅有少数晚期复发。似乎最新的两种方案可能使大约一半的患者得到治愈。在过去17年中,494例年龄在15至70岁以上的急性非淋巴细胞白血病(ANLL)成人患者接受了五种连续的不同强度多药治疗方案中的一种(阿糖胞苷 + 6 - 硫鸟嘌呤 [n = 36];L6 [n = 101];L12 [n = 104];L14/14M [n = 121];L16/16M [n = 132])。骨髓增生异常综合征患者通常在发展为急性白血病之前不进行治疗,但之后纳入研究并计入结果。其他肿瘤性疾病治疗后发生的继发性白血病未纳入。完全缓解率在47%至64%之间相当稳定,缓解的中位持续时间在9至21个月之间。强化治疗L14和L16方案与更多早期死亡相关,并未显著提高缓解发生率、缓解持续时间或生存率。对于所有方案,大多数复发发生在最初2年内,但复发在4年内仍以逐渐降低的速率发生,偶尔甚至更晚。尽管大约10%至15%的ANLL成人患者现在显然通过联合化疗得到治愈,但尽管付出了巨大努力,在过去十年中进展甚微,迫切需要更具选择性和有效性的治疗形式。