VA Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
Headache. 2022 Mar;62(3):306-318. doi: 10.1111/head.14277. Epub 2022 Mar 16.
Comprehensive headache care involves numerous specialties and components that have not been well documented or standardized. This study aimed to elicit best practices and characterize important elements of care to be provided in multidisciplinary headache centers.
Qualitative, semi-structured telephone interviews with a purposive sample of headache neurology specialists from across the US, using open-ended questions. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and coded. Coded data were further analyzed using immersion/crystallization techniques for final interpretation.
Mean years providing headache care was 17.7 (SD = 10.6). Twelve of the 13 participants held United Council for Neurologic Subspecialties headache certification. Six described their practice site as providing multidisciplinary headache care. Participants explained most of their patients had seen multiple doctors over many years, and had tried numerous unsuccessful treatments. They noted patients with chronic headache frequently present with comorbidities and become stigmatized. All participants asserted successful care depends on taking time to talk with and listen to patients, gain understanding, and earn trust. All participants believed multidisciplinary care is essential within a comprehensive headache center, along with staffing enough headache specialists, implementing detailed headache intake and follow-up protocols, and providing the newest medications, neuromodulation devices, botulinum toxin injections, monoclonal antibodies, nerve blocks and infusions, and treatment from a health psychologist. Other essential services for a headache center are other behavioral health practitioners providing cognitive behavioral therapy, mindfulness, biofeedback and pain management; and autonomic neurology, neuropsychology, vestibular audiology, sleep medicine, physical therapy, occupational therapy, exercise physiology, speech therapy, nutrition, complementary integrative health modalities, and highly trained support staff.
While headache neurology specialists form the backbone of headache care, experts interviewed for this study maintained their specialty is just one of many types of care needed to adequately treat patients with chronic headache, and this is best provided in a comprehensive, multidisciplinary center.
综合头痛护理涉及众多尚未得到充分记录或标准化的专业和组成部分。本研究旨在引出最佳实践并描述多学科头痛中心提供护理的重要要素。
采用开放式问题,对美国各地的头痛神经病学专家进行了定性、半结构化的电话访谈,采用了目的抽样。对访谈进行了记录、转录和编码。使用沉浸/结晶技术对编码数据进行进一步分析,以进行最终解释。
提供头痛护理的平均年限为 17.7 年(SD=10.6)。13 名参与者中有 12 名持有联合神经病学专业委员会头痛认证。6 名参与者描述他们的实践地点提供多学科头痛护理。参与者解释说,他们的大多数患者多年来看过多个医生,并尝试过许多不成功的治疗方法。他们指出,慢性头痛患者经常伴有合并症,并受到歧视。所有参与者都断言,成功的护理取决于花时间与患者交谈、倾听、建立理解和赢得信任。所有参与者都认为,多学科护理对于综合头痛中心至关重要,还需要足够数量的头痛专家、实施详细的头痛入组和随访方案,以及提供最新的药物、神经调节设备、肉毒杆菌毒素注射、单克隆抗体、神经阻滞和输注,以及来自健康心理学家的治疗。头痛中心的其他必要服务包括其他行为健康从业者提供认知行为疗法、正念、生物反馈和疼痛管理;以及自主神经病学、神经心理学、前庭耳科学、睡眠医学、物理治疗、职业治疗、运动生理学、言语治疗、营养、补充综合健康模式以及高度训练的支持人员。
虽然头痛神经病学专家是头痛护理的核心,但接受采访的专家认为,他们的专业知识只是治疗慢性头痛患者所需的众多护理类型之一,最好在综合性、多学科中心提供这种护理。