Kato Tsuguhiko, Ochi Manami, Kachi Yuko, Suto Maiko, Otsuka Miyako, Takehara Kenji
Department of Social Medicine, National Center for Child Health and Development.
Department of Health and Welfare Services, National Institute of Public Health.
Nihon Koshu Eisei Zasshi. 2022 May 24;69(5):321-337. doi: 10.11236/jph.21-040. Epub 2022 Mar 16.
Objectives Recently, paternal involvement in childcare has been gaining public attention in Japan. However, studies on the influences of active paternal involvement remain scarce. This study aimed to review the findings on the influence of paternal involvement in childcare on mothers, children, and fathers themselves from studies conducted in Japan and published mainly after 2010. Additionally, we examined methodological issues that need to be addressed when researchers conduct studies on paternal involvement in the future.Methods We reviewed 26 journal articles (22 in Japanese and 4 in English) from four databases: "Igaku Chuo Zasshi Web (Japana Centra Revuo Medicina History and Activities)," JSTPlus, JMEDPlus, and PubMed with conditions such as studies conducted in Japan, families with young children, and questionnaire-based quantitative studies. We described respondents (mothers, fathers, or both) and assessed paternal involvement in childcare, outcomes, and findings.Results We reviewed studies on paternal involvement in childcare published in Japanese after 2010 and English after 2000 and observed two trends across the studies. The first was that if mothers acknowledge active paternal involvement in childcare, mothers' parenting stress seemed to be lower, and they seemed to be happier. Moreover, for children's health and development, active paternal involvement seemed to be associated with positive results, such as prevention of unintentional injuries and obesity. However, in the second trend, we observed that active paternal involvement, assessed by the fathers themselves, were often not associated with lower parenting stress among mothers. We also could not observe a consistent trend on the findings related to the influences on fathers, due to the limited number of studies. We observed that assessment of paternal involvement in childcare was inconsistent across studies included in this review.Conclusion With more social pressure for fathers to be actively involved in childcare, public interest for the influence would be heightened. For future studies, better ways of assessing the quantity and content of paternal involvement in childcare need to be discussed.
目标 近年来,父亲参与育儿在日本受到了公众的关注。然而,关于父亲积极参与育儿的影响的研究仍然很少。本研究旨在回顾2010年以后在日本进行并主要以英文发表的研究中,父亲参与育儿对母亲、孩子和父亲自身影响的研究结果。此外,我们还研究了研究人员未来在进行父亲参与育儿相关研究时需要解决的方法学问题。
方法 我们从四个数据库中检索了26篇期刊文章(22篇日语和4篇英语):“医学中央杂志网络版(日本医学中央杂志历史与活动)”、JSTPlus、JMEDPlus和PubMed,检索条件包括在日本进行的研究、有幼儿的家庭以及基于问卷的定量研究。我们描述了受访者(母亲、父亲或双方),并评估了父亲对育儿的参与情况、结果和研究发现。
结果 我们回顾了2010年以后以日语发表以及2000年以后以英语发表的关于父亲参与育儿的研究,发现这些研究呈现出两种趋势。第一种趋势是,如果母亲认可父亲积极参与育儿,母亲的育儿压力似乎会降低,而且她们似乎会更幸福。此外,对于孩子的健康和发展,父亲的积极参与似乎与预防意外伤害和肥胖等积极结果相关。然而,在第二种趋势中,我们发现,由父亲自己评估的积极参与育儿,往往与母亲较低的育儿压力无关。由于研究数量有限,我们也未能观察到关于对父亲影响的研究结果的一致趋势。我们发现,本综述纳入的研究中,对父亲参与育儿的评估并不一致。
结论 随着社会对父亲积极参与育儿的压力增大,公众对其影响的关注度将会提高。对于未来的研究,需要探讨更好的评估父亲参与育儿的数量和内容的方法。