Salgaonkar Sweta V, Kulkarni Aarti D, Chapane Sunil P
Department of Anesthesia, Seth GSMC and KEM Hospital, Parel, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India.
J Anaesthesiol Clin Pharmacol. 2021 Oct-Dec;37(4):548-553. doi: 10.4103/joacp.JOACP_414_19. Epub 2022 Jan 6.
Anaesthesiologists have few opportunities to communicate with patients especially in preoperative period for various reasons. If these opportunities are not well utilized, anesthesiologists may not be able to educate patients about anaesthesia related issues. The aim of this study was to assess communication skill (CS) exhibited by the anesthesiology residents during the process of preoperative visit and informed consent.
This was a pre and post intervention questionnaire based study carried out in a presurgical ward of a tertiary hospital. During the process of preoperative visit and informed consent, fourteen of the second year anesthesia residents were assessed by faculty members for various aspects of CS using validated questionnaire on 3-point Likert's scale, before and after CS workshop. Residents' perception about workshop and patient satisfaction with regards to the preoperative visit and process of informed consent was assessed. Results were described in percentage value and a qualitative analysis was carried out.
While none of the residents exhibited 'excellent CS score' in the pre-workshop phase, six (42.86%) achieved the same after the workshop. One resident, who had 'poor CS score' moved to higher category score post workshop. The behavioural traits of professionalism, empathy, risk explanation and written consent showed statistically significant improvements post intervention by Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test, with value < 0.05. All residents felt that good communication can improve patient satisfaction and CS training should be part of the post graduate curriculum.
Conduct of CS workshop for anesthesia residents improved certain behavioral traits during anaesthesia preoperative visit and informed consent process. This important nontechnical skill of CS, may not be uniformly acquired during clinical training and should be specifically taught and evaluated as part of post graduate curriculum.
由于各种原因,麻醉医生与患者沟通的机会很少,尤其是在术前阶段。如果这些机会没有得到充分利用,麻醉医生可能无法就麻醉相关问题对患者进行教育。本研究的目的是评估麻醉科住院医师在术前访视和知情同意过程中表现出的沟通技巧(CS)。
这是一项在三级医院外科病房进行的基于干预前后问卷调查的研究。在术前访视和知情同意过程中,14名二年级麻醉住院医师在沟通技巧培训工作坊前后,由教员使用经过验证的3点李克特量表问卷对沟通技巧的各个方面进行评估。评估了住院医师对工作坊的看法以及患者对术前访视和知情同意过程的满意度。结果以百分比值描述,并进行了定性分析。
在工作坊前阶段,没有住院医师表现出“优秀的沟通技巧得分”,而在工作坊后,有6名(42.86%)达到了相同水平。一名沟通技巧得分“较差”的住院医师在工作坊后提升到了更高的得分类别。通过威尔科克森符号秩检验,专业精神、同理心、风险解释和书面同意的行为特征在干预后显示出统计学上的显著改善,P值<0.05。所有住院医师都认为良好的沟通可以提高患者满意度,沟通技巧培训应该成为研究生课程的一部分。
为麻醉住院医师举办沟通技巧工作坊,改善了麻醉术前访视和知情同意过程中的某些行为特征。这种重要的非技术技能——沟通技巧,可能在临床培训期间无法统一获得,应该作为研究生课程的一部分进行专门教授和评估。