Hu Kun, Chen Yu, Guo Feng, Wang Xin
College of Human Kinesiology, Shenyang Sport University, Shenyang, China.
Front Physiol. 2022 Mar 9;13:834397. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2022.834397. eCollection 2022.
Whether transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) can improve upper limb muscle strength and endurance in healthy subjects is still controversial. This article reviews the relevant literature on the use of tDCS to improve upper limb muscle strength and endurance in healthy individuals.
We systematically searched the Cochrane Library, PubMed, EMBASE, and the Web of Science until September 4, 2021. Randomized parallel or crossover experimental studies on the effects of tDCS on upper limb muscle strength and endurance in healthy individuals were included. Review Manager 5.3 software was used to evaluate methodological quality and analyze the combined effect of the included literature.
Twelve studies (189 participants) were included in the qualitative synthesis, and nine studies (146 participants) were included in the meta-analysis. Compared with the control group, the tDCS intervention had no significant effect on improving upper limb muscle strength [I = 0%, 95% CI (-0.79, 0.23), = 0.98, MD = 0.01]. In this analysis, tDCS had a significant heterogeneity (I = 87%) in improving upper limb muscle endurance compared with the control group. After the subgroup analysis and the sensitivity analysis, the source of heterogeneity was excluded. The final results showed that tDCS had a significant effect on improving upper limb muscle endurance [I = 0%, 95% CI (1.91, 4.83), < 0.00001, MD = 3.37].
tDCS has no significant effect on improvement of upper limb muscle strength, but has a significant effect on improving upper limb endurance performance (especially on the non-dominant side).
经颅直流电刺激(tDCS)能否改善健康受试者的上肢肌肉力量和耐力仍存在争议。本文综述了关于使用tDCS改善健康个体上肢肌肉力量和耐力的相关文献。
我们系统检索了Cochrane图书馆、PubMed、EMBASE和科学网,检索截至2021年9月4日。纳入了关于tDCS对健康个体上肢肌肉力量和耐力影响的随机平行或交叉实验研究。使用Review Manager 5.3软件评估方法学质量并分析纳入文献的合并效应。
定性综合分析纳入了12项研究(189名参与者),荟萃分析纳入了9项研究(146名参与者)。与对照组相比,tDCS干预对改善上肢肌肉力量无显著效果[I² = 0%,95%CI(-0.79,0.23),P = 0.98,MD = 0.01]。在该分析中,与对照组相比,tDCS在改善上肢肌肉耐力方面存在显著异质性(I² = 87%)。经过亚组分析和敏感性分析,排除了异质性来源。最终结果显示,tDCS对改善上肢肌肉耐力有显著效果[I² = 0%,95%CI(1.91,4.83),P < 0.00001,MD = 3.37]。
tDCS对改善上肢肌肉力量无显著效果,但对改善上肢耐力表现有显著效果(尤其是对非优势侧)。