(扩展的)软骨发育不全枕大孔评分具有良好的观察者可靠性。
The (extended) achondroplasia foramen magnum score has good observer reliability.
作者信息
Jenko Nathan, Connolly Daniel J A, Raghavan Ashok, Fernandes James A, Ushewokunze Shungu, Elphick Heather E, Arundel Paul, Alhun Utku, Offiah Amaka C
机构信息
Department of Radiology, Sheffield Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Glossop Road, Sheffield, S10 2JF, UK.
Sheffield Children's Hospital NHS Foundation Trust, Sheffield, UK.
出版信息
Pediatr Radiol. 2022 Jul;52(8):1512-1520. doi: 10.1007/s00247-022-05348-0. Epub 2022 Apr 9.
BACKGROUND
Achondroplasia is the most common skeletal dysplasia. A significant complication is foramen magnum stenosis. When severe, compression of the spinal cord may result in sleep apnea, sudden respiratory arrest and death. To avoid complications, surgical decompression of the craniocervical junction is offered in at-risk cases. However, practice varies among centres. To standardize magnetic resonance (MR) reporting, the achondroplasia foramen magnum score was recently developed. The reliability of the score has not been assessed.
OBJECTIVE
To assess the interobserver reliability of the achondroplasia foramen magnum score.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Base of skull imaging of children with achondroplasia under the care of Sheffield Children's Hospital was retrospectively and independently reviewed by four observers using the achondroplasia foramen magnum score. Two-way random-effects intraclass coefficient (ICC) was used to assess inter- and intra-observer reliability.
RESULTS
Forty-nine eligible cases and five controls were included. Of these, 10 were scored normal, 17 had a median score of 1 (mild narrowing), 11 had a median score of 2 (effacement of cerebral spinal fluid), 10 had a score of 3 (compression of cord) and 6 had a median score of 4 (cord myelopathic change). Interobserver ICC was 0.72 (95% confidence interval = 0.62-0.81). Intra-observer ICC ranged from 0.60 to 0.86. Reasons for reader disagreement included flow void artefact, subtle T2 cord signal and myelopathic T2 cord change disproportionate to canal narrowing.
CONCLUSION
The achondroplasia foramen magnum score has good interobserver reliability. Imaging features leading to interobserver disagreement have been identified. Further research is required to prospectively validate the score against clinical outcomes.
背景
软骨发育不全是最常见的骨骼发育异常。一个重要的并发症是枕骨大孔狭窄。严重时,脊髓受压可能导致睡眠呼吸暂停、突然呼吸骤停和死亡。为避免并发症,对于有风险的病例会进行颅颈交界区的手术减压。然而,各中心的做法有所不同。为了规范磁共振(MR)报告,最近制定了软骨发育不全枕骨大孔评分。该评分的可靠性尚未得到评估。
目的
评估软骨发育不全枕骨大孔评分的观察者间可靠性。
材料与方法
谢菲尔德儿童医院所诊治的软骨发育不全患儿的颅骨底部影像由四名观察者使用软骨发育不全枕骨大孔评分进行回顾性独立评估。采用双向随机效应组内相关系数(ICC)评估观察者间和观察者内的可靠性。
结果
纳入49例符合条件的病例和5例对照。其中,10例评分正常,17例中位数评分为1(轻度狭窄),11例中位数评分为2(脑脊液消失),10例评分为3(脊髓受压),6例中位数评分为4(脊髓病变改变)。观察者间ICC为0.72(95%置信区间=0.62-0.81)。观察者内ICC范围为0.60至0.86。读者意见不一致的原因包括血流空洞伪影、细微的T2脊髓信号以及与椎管狭窄不成比例的脊髓病变T2改变。
结论
软骨发育不全枕骨大孔评分具有良好的观察者间可靠性。已确定导致观察者间意见不一致的影像特征。需要进一步研究以根据临床结果对该评分进行前瞻性验证。