Talpur Noureen, Abdulkadir Said Jadid, Alhussian Hitham, Hasan Mohd Hilmi, Aziz Norshakirah, Bamhdi Alwi
Centre for Research in Data Science (CeRDaS), Computer Information Science Department, Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS, Seri Iskandar, Perak, Malaysia.
Department of Computer Sciences, College of Computing, Al Qunfudhah, Umm Al-Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia.
Artif Intell Rev. 2023;56(2):865-913. doi: 10.1007/s10462-022-10188-3. Epub 2022 Apr 13.
Deep neural networks (DNN) have remarkably progressed in applications involving large and complex datasets but have been criticized as a black-box. This downside has recently become a motivation for the research community to pursue the ideas of hybrid approaches, resulting in novel hybrid systems classified as deep neuro-fuzzy systems (DNFS). Studies regarding the implementation of DNFS have rapidly increased in the domains of computing, healthcare, transportation, and finance with high interpretability and reasonable accuracy. However, relatively few survey studies have been found in the literature to provide a comprehensive insight into this domain. Therefore, this study aims to perform a systematic review to evaluate the current progress, trends, arising issues, research gaps, challenges, and future scope related to DNFS studies. A study mapping process was prepared to guide a systematic search for publications related to DNFS published between 2015 and 2020 using five established scientific directories. As a result, a total of 105 studies were identified and critically analyzed to address research questions with the objectives: (i) to understand the concept of DNFS; (ii) to find out DNFS optimization methods; (iii) to visualize the intensity of work carried out in DNFS domain; and (iv) to highlight DNFS application subjects and domains. We believe that this study provides up-to-date guidance for future research in the DNFS domain, allowing for more effective advancement in techniques and processes. The analysis made in this review proves that DNFS-based research is actively growing with a substantial implementation and application scope in the future.
深度神经网络(DNN)在涉及大型复杂数据集的应用中取得了显著进展,但却被批评为黑箱模型。这一缺点最近促使研究界探索混合方法的思路,从而产生了被归类为深度神经模糊系统(DNFS)的新型混合系统。在计算、医疗、交通和金融等领域,关于DNFS实现的研究迅速增加,其具有高可解释性和合理的准确性。然而,在文献中发现相对较少的综述研究能全面洞察这一领域。因此,本研究旨在进行系统综述,以评估与DNFS研究相关的当前进展、趋势、出现的问题、研究差距、挑战和未来前景。准备了一个研究映射过程,以指导使用五个既定的科学目录系统搜索2015年至2020年间发表的与DNFS相关的出版物。结果,共识别并批判性分析了105项研究,以解决以下目标的研究问题:(i)理解DNFS的概念;(ii)找出DNFS优化方法;(iii)可视化DNFS领域开展的工作强度;(iv)突出DNFS的应用主题和领域。我们相信,本研究为DNFS领域的未来研究提供了最新指导,有助于在技术和流程上更有效地推进。本综述中的分析证明,基于DNFS的研究正在积极发展,未来具有广泛的实施和应用范围。