Department of Internal Medicine, University Hospital Gaffrée and Guinle, Federal University of the State of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
Department of Neurology, Neurology Post-Graduate Program, University Hospital Gaffrée and Guinle, Federal University of the State of Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
PLoS One. 2022 May 3;17(5):e0267556. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0267556. eCollection 2022.
Anxiety symptoms (AS) are exacerbated in healthcare workers (HCWs) during the COVID-19 pandemic. Spirituality is known to protect against AS in the general population and it is a construct that differs from religion. It can be assessed using structured questionnaires. A validated questionnaire disclosed three spirituality dimensions: peace, meaning, and faith. In HCWs we investigated the predictors of chronic anxiety (pre-COVID-19 and during the pandemic) and acute anxiety (only during the pandemic), including spirituality in the model. Then, we verified which spirituality dimensions predicted chronic and acute anxiety. Lastly, we studied group differences between the mean scores of these spirituality dimensions.
The study was carried out in a Brazilian Hospital. HCWs (n = 118) were assessed for spirituality at a single time-point. They were also asked about AS that had started pre-COVID-19 and persisted during the pandemic (chronic anxiety), and AS that had started only during the pandemic (acute anxiety). The subjects without chronic anxiety were subdivided into two other groups: acute anxiety and without chronic and acute anxiety. Forward stepwise logistic regressions were used to find the significant AS predictors. First, the model considered sex, age, religious affiliation, and spirituality. Then, the analysis were performed considering only the three spirituality dimensions. Group means differences in the spirituality dimensions were compared using univariate ANCOVAS followed by T-tests.
Spirituality was the most realible predictor of chronic (OR = 0.818; 95%CI:0.752-0.890; p<0.001) and acute anxiety (OR = 0.727; 95%CI:0.601-0.881; p = 0.001). Peace alone predicted chronic anxiety (OR = 0.619; 95%CI:0.516-0.744; p<0.001) while for acute anxiety both peace (OR:0.517; 95%CI:0.340-0.787; p = 0.002), and faith (OR:0.674; 95%CI:0.509-0.892; p = 0.006) significantly contributed to the model. Faith was significantly higher in subjects without AS.
Higher spirituality protected against chronic and acute anxiety. Faith and peace spirituality dimensions conferred protection against acute anxiety during the pandemic.
在 COVID-19 大流行期间,医护人员(HCWs)的焦虑症状(AS)加剧。已知灵性在普通人群中可以预防 AS,它是一种与宗教不同的结构。可以使用结构化问卷进行评估。经过验证的问卷揭示了三个灵性维度:和平、意义和信仰。在 HCWs 中,我们研究了慢性焦虑(COVID-19 之前和大流行期间)和急性焦虑(仅在大流行期间)的预测因素,并在模型中包括了灵性。然后,我们验证了哪些灵性维度可以预测慢性和急性焦虑。最后,我们研究了这些灵性维度的平均分数之间的组间差异。
该研究在巴西的一家医院进行。在单个时间点评估了 HCWs 的灵性。他们还被问及在 COVID-19 之前开始并在大流行期间持续存在的 AS(慢性焦虑),以及仅在大流行期间开始的 AS(急性焦虑)。没有慢性焦虑的受试者被进一步分为另外两组:急性焦虑和没有慢性和急性焦虑。使用向前逐步逻辑回归来寻找显著的 AS 预测因素。首先,该模型考虑了性别、年龄、宗教信仰和灵性。然后,仅考虑三个灵性维度进行分析。使用单变量 ANCOVAS 比较灵性维度的组间均值差异,然后进行 T 检验。
灵性是慢性(OR = 0.818;95%CI:0.752-0.890;p<0.001)和急性焦虑(OR = 0.727;95%CI:0.601-0.881;p = 0.001)最可靠的预测因素。只有和平单独预测慢性焦虑(OR = 0.619;95%CI:0.516-0.744;p<0.001),而对于急性焦虑,和平(OR:0.517;95%CI:0.340-0.787;p = 0.002)和信仰(OR:0.674;95%CI:0.509-0.892;p = 0.006)都为模型做出了显著贡献。无 AS 受试者的信仰明显更高。
较高的灵性可预防慢性和急性焦虑。信仰和和平灵性维度在大流行期间为急性焦虑提供了保护。