Islatravir (ISL) is a nucleoside reverse transcriptase translocation inhibitor (NRTTI) that inhibits human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) reverse transcription by blocking reverse transcriptase (RT) translocation on the primer:template. ISL is being developed for the treatment of HIV-1 infection. To expand our knowledge of viral variants that may confer reduced susceptibility to ISL, resistance selection studies were conducted with wild-type (WT) subtype A, B, and C viruses. RT mutations encoding M184I and M184V were the most frequently observed changes. Selection studies were also initiated with virus containing a single known resistance-associated mutation in RT (K65R, L74I, V90I, M184I, or M184V), and no additional mutations were observed. Antiviral activity assays were performed on variants that emerged in selection studies to determine their impact. M184I and M184V were the only single-codon substitutions that reduced susceptibility >2-fold compared to WT. A114S was an emergent substitution that when combined with other substitutions further reduced susceptibility >2-fold. Viruses containing A114S in combination with M184V did not replicate in primary blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs), consistent with the rare occurrence of the combination in clinical samples. While A114S conferred reduced susceptibility to ISL, it increased susceptibility to approved nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NRTIs). This differential impact of A114S on ISL, an NRTTI, compared to NRTIs likely results from the different mechanisms of action. Altogether, the results demonstrate that ISL has a high barrier to resistance and a differentiated mechanism compared to approved NRTIs.