Vanderbilt University School of Medicine (VUSM), Nashville, TN, USA.
Department of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, 330 Brookline Avenue, Boston, MA, 02215, USA.
J Community Health. 2022 Oct;47(5):759-764. doi: 10.1007/s10900-022-01105-4. Epub 2022 Jun 9.
Examination of screening guideline concordance can help clinics and institutions identify and understand disparities within their own practices. We conducted a study to examine whether screening completion rates within a student-run free clinic (SRFC) reflected, exacerbated, or narrowed population-level disparities in outcomes by race/ethnicity and primary language. We compared completion rates for cervical cancer (n = 114), diabetic retinopathy (n = 91), colorectal cancer (n = 114), and breast cancer (n = 63) by race/ethnicity (Black, n = 37; Hispanic, n = 133; white, n = 54; other, n = 29) and primary language (English, n = 106; Spanish, n = 136; other, n = 11) among patients at Shade tree clinic (STC), an SFRC in Nashville, TN. There were no differences in screening completion rate by race/ethnicity, and Spanish-speaking patients had slightly higher rates of cervical cancer screening [91% (95% confidence interval 84-97%)] than English-speaking patients [72% (57-86%)]. Overall screening rates were comparable to national averages, and in the case of screenings performed within clinic-cervical cancer [82%; (75-89%)] and diabetic retinopathy screening [86% (79-92%)]-exceeded national averages and/or affiliated academic medical center goals. These findings extend the existing literature supporting the ability of SRFCs to provide effective care by also demonstrating one measure of equity in clinic processes, providing a framework for future studies of equity within SRFCs and traditional primary care practices.
检查筛查指南的一致性可以帮助诊所和机构识别并理解其自身实践中的差异。我们进行了一项研究,以检查学生经营的免费诊所 (SRFC) 内的筛查完成率是否反映、加剧或缩小了种族/民族和主要语言的人群水平差异。我们比较了纳什维尔 TN 的 Shade tree 诊所 (STC) 中,按种族/民族 (黑人,n=37;西班牙裔,n=133;白人,n=54;其他,n=29) 和主要语言 (英语,n=106;西班牙语,n=136;其他,n=11) 的患者中,宫颈癌 (n=114)、糖尿病视网膜病变 (n=91)、结直肠癌 (n=114) 和乳腺癌 (n=63) 的筛查完成率。种族/民族之间的筛查完成率没有差异,西班牙语患者的宫颈癌筛查率略高[91%(84-97%)],而英语患者为[72%(57-86%)]。总体筛查率与全国平均水平相当,而在诊所进行的筛查中,宫颈癌筛查率[82%;(75-89%)]和糖尿病视网膜病变筛查率[86%(79-92%)]则超过了全国平均水平和/或附属学术医疗中心的目标。这些发现扩展了现有的文献,支持了 SRFC 提供有效护理的能力,同时也证明了诊所流程中公平性的一个衡量标准,为未来在 SRFC 和传统初级保健实践中进行公平性研究提供了框架。