Wang Wen, Leichtman Alan B, Rees Michael A, Song Peter X-K, Ashby Valarie B, Shearon Tempie, Kalbfleisch John D
Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Kidney Epidemiology and Cost Center, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
Kidney Int Rep. 2022 Mar 28;7(6):1278-1288. doi: 10.1016/j.ekir.2022.03.023. eCollection 2022 Jun.
Rather than generating 1 transplant by directly donating to a candidate on the waitlist, deceased donors (DDs) could achieve additional transplants by donating to a candidate in a kidney paired donation (KPD) pool, thereby, initiating a chain that ends with a living donor (LD) donating to a candidate on the waitlist. We model outcomes arising from various strategies that allow DDs to initiate KPD chains.
We base simulations on actual 2016 to 2017 US DD and waitlist data and use simulated KPD pools to model DD-initiated KPD chains. We also consider methods to assess and overcome the primary criticism of this approach, namely the potential to disadvantage blood type O-waitlisted candidates.
Compared with shorter DD-initiated KPD chains, longer chains increase the number of KPD transplants by up to 5% and reduce the number of DDs allocated to the KPD pool by 25%. These strategies increase the overall number of blood type O transplants and make LDs available to candidates on the waitlist. Restricting allocation of blood type O DDs to require ending KPD chains with LD blood type O donations to the waitlist markedly reduces the number of KPD transplants achieved.
Allocating fewer than 3% of DD to initiate KPD chains could increase the number of kidney transplants by up to 290 annually. Such use of DDs allows additional transplantation of highly sensitized and blood type O KPD candidates. Collectively, patients of each blood type, including blood type O, would benefit from the proposed strategies.
已故捐赠者(DDs)并非直接将器官捐赠给等待名单上的候选者以促成1例移植,而是可以通过将器官捐赠给肾脏配对捐赠(KPD)库中的候选者来实现更多移植,从而启动一条以活体捐赠者(LD)向等待名单上的候选者捐赠器官告终的链条。我们对允许DDs启动KPD链条的各种策略所产生的结果进行建模。
我们以2016年至2017年美国实际的DD和等待名单数据为基础进行模拟,并使用模拟的KPD库对DD启动的KPD链条进行建模。我们还考虑了评估和克服对该方法主要批评的方法,即可能对血型为O型的等待名单上的候选者不利。
与较短的DD启动的KPD链条相比,较长的链条可使KPD移植数量增加多达5%,并使分配到KPD库的DD数量减少25%。这些策略增加了O型血移植的总数,并使活体捐赠者能够为等待名单上的候选者所用。限制O型血DD的分配,要求以向等待名单上的候选者进行O型血活体捐赠来结束KPD链条,会显著减少实现的KPD移植数量。
将不到3%的DD分配用于启动KPD链条,每年可使肾脏移植数量增加多达290例。这种对DD的使用方式允许对高敏和O型血KPD候选者进行额外移植。总体而言,包括O型血在内的每种血型的患者都将从所提出的策略中受益。