Volaski Harrison, Sharfman Zachary T, Levy I Martin
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Montefiore Medical Center, Bronx, New York.
Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, New York.
JB JS Open Access. 2022 Jun 7;7(2). doi: 10.2106/JBJS.OA.21.00161. eCollection 2022 Apr-Jun.
Online learning platforms are a staple of orthopaedic resident education. These platforms typically address a user's knowledge base, aiming to improve OITE and AAOS Board Examination scores. Orthopaedic residents often use these platforms as their primary educational resource. However, an orthopaedic surgeon is more than an orthopaedic knowledge base; acquisition of clinical acumen is integral as well. We sought to investigate the following: From a learner's and educator's perspective, do Orthobullets (OB) and Clinical Classroom (CC) contribute to both knowledge base and clinical acumen?
Thirty residents and 16 attending surgeons at a single institution were assigned to review topics and complete questions on either the OB and CC platform. Participants then filled out surveys regarding the platform they were assigned, switched platforms, and completed a final survey. Independent-samples Student tests and χ tests were used to analyze differences in continuous and categorical data.
Residents and attendings reported a preference for OB for fact acquisition, relevance to the OITE, and explanation of answers. Senior residents (PGY5) and attending surgeons reported that CC had a greater impact on their clinical acumen. Junior residents (PGY1, PGY2, and PGY3) reported the opposite. Participants responded that both platforms expand a learner's knowledge base and clinical acumen.
Learners and educators felt both platforms addressed knowledge base and clinical acumen. Junior residents reported a preference for OB to CC to advance their knowledge base and clinical acumen, but senior residents and attendings felt the opposite was true. Based on survey responses, these platforms were found to be additive, complementary, and that their value to the learner changes during the course of residency education.
III.
在线学习平台是骨科住院医师教育的主要组成部分。这些平台通常针对用户的知识库,旨在提高骨科住院医师培训考试(OITE)和美国骨科医师学会(AAOS)委员会考试的成绩。骨科住院医师经常将这些平台作为他们的主要教育资源。然而,一名骨科外科医生不仅仅是一个骨科知识库;临床敏锐度的培养同样不可或缺。我们试图研究以下问题:从学习者和教育者的角度来看,Orthobullets(OB)和临床课堂(CC)是否有助于提高知识库和临床敏锐度?
在单一机构中,30名住院医师和16名主治医生被分配去复习相关主题并在OB和CC平台上完成问题。参与者随后填写关于他们所分配平台的调查问卷,更换平台后,再完成一份最终调查问卷。使用独立样本t检验和χ检验来分析连续数据和分类数据的差异。
住院医师和主治医生表示,在获取事实、与OITE的相关性以及答案解释方面,他们更喜欢OB。高年资住院医师(PGY5)和主治医生报告称,CC对他们的临床敏锐度有更大影响。低年资住院医师(PGY1、PGY2和PGY3)则持相反观点。参与者回应称,两个平台都扩展了学习者的知识库和临床敏锐度。
学习者和教育者认为两个平台都有助于提高知识库和临床敏锐度。低年资住院医师表示,相对于CC,他们更喜欢OB来提升自己的知识库和临床敏锐度,但高年资住院医师和主治医生则持相反观点。根据调查反馈,发现这些平台具有累加性、互补性,并且它们对学习者的价值在住院医师教育过程中会发生变化。
III级。