Fan Dan-Dan, Liu Hong-Ling, Yang Liu-Yan
State Key Laboratory of Pollution Control and Resource Reuse, School of Environment, Nanjing University, Nanjing 210023, China.
Huan Jing Ke Xue. 2022 Jun 8;43(6):2987-2995. doi: 10.13227/j.hjkx.202109064.
This study was conducted in response to the current situation in our country in which neonicotinoid pesticides (NNIs) are used in large quantities and their concentration in surface water is gradually increasing. Based on the species sensitivity distribution (SSD), the hazard quotient (HQ) and probabilistic risk assessment (PRA) were used to compare single and mixture risks of NNIs in the surface water in China. The target and recommended values of NNIs in China's surface water quality supervision were also presented. The results showed that:① in the single acute hazard assessment, imidacloprid (IMI) was the most harmful insecticide, and in the single chronic hazard assessment, imidacloprid (IMI) and acetamiprid (ACE) were more harmful. Furthermore, insects were the most sensitive creatures. ② Hainan province was the region with the highest single acute and chronic hazard in the study area. ③ Based on the joint probability curves of five neonicotinoids, the probability in which 5% of species would be affected by long-term exposure was approximately 91.12%. Thus, the combined ecological risk of these five neonicotinoids cannot be ignored. ④ Based on the toxicity reference value from SSD and the combined results of HQ and PRA, the regulatory values of surface water quality in China were as follows:acetamiprid (ACE) 0.04 μg·L, clothianidin (CLO) 0.22 μg·L, imidacloprid (IMI) 0.01 μg·L, thiacloprid (THI) 0.03 μg·L, and thiamethoxam (THIA) 0.24 μg·L. In short, the concentration of NNIs in the surface water in China has threatened the safety of aquatic organisms, and its supervision must be improved.
本研究是针对我国新烟碱类农药(NNIs)大量使用且其在地表水中的浓度逐渐上升的现状开展的。基于物种敏感性分布(SSD),采用危害商数(HQ)和概率风险评估(PRA)来比较我国地表水中NNIs的单一和混合风险。还给出了我国地表水水质监测中NNIs的目标值和推荐值。结果表明:①在单一急性危害评估中,吡虫啉(IMI)是最具危害性的杀虫剂,在单一慢性危害评估中,吡虫啉(IMI)和啶虫脒(ACE)的危害性更大。此外,昆虫是最敏感的生物。②海南省是研究区域内单一急性和慢性危害最高的地区。③基于五种新烟碱类农药的联合概率曲线,5%的物种长期暴露会受到影响的概率约为91.12%。因此,这五种新烟碱类农药的综合生态风险不容忽视。④基于SSD的毒性参考值以及HQ和PRA的综合结果,我国地表水水质的监管值如下:啶虫脒(ACE)0.04μg·L,噻虫胺(CLO)0.22μg·L,吡虫啉(IMI)0.01μg·L,噻虫啉(THI)0.03μg·L,噻虫嗪(THIA)0.24μg·L。总之,我国地表水中NNIs的浓度已威胁到水生生物的安全,必须加强对其的监管。