Jayasundara Maleesa Sawaneeth, Thivaharan Yalini, Muthulingam Thanushan, Borukgama Nirmal, Kulathunga Deshan L, Kitulwatte Indira D G
Acad Forensic Pathol. 2022 Mar;12(1):15-22. doi: 10.1177/19253621211065616. Epub 2021 Dec 15.
Violence with physical assault is a common cause of morbidity and mortality prevalent but not limited to underdeveloped countries. The opinion of the forensic expert is often indispensable in such cases to determine the penalties. This study was planned to describe the pattern of presentation of the victims and evaluate the strengths and limitations in formulating a scientific medicolegal opinion based on the findings of the victim.
A retrospective descriptive study based on the case records of the victims of assault admitted to Colombo North Teaching Hospital, Ragama, Sri Lanka, was conducted for four years.
Out of the 400 victims, the majority (72% n = 290) were males and of the age-group of 21 to 40 (n = 216). The reason for assault in the majority was sudden provocation (n = 99, 25%), followed by previous long-duration enmity (n = 89, 22%). The majority (83%) had isolated blunt force trauma, and the injuries were nongrievous (74%). Defense injuries were significantly associated with attempted defense (p = 0.000) and sharp force trauma (p = 0.002). The underlying reason for the assault was not significantly associated with the causative weapon (p = 0.228) or body region injured (p = 0.195).
Even though the presentation and the pattern of injures are definitely of value in formulating a scientific opinion, the study identified the limitations of the forensic experts, and the need for a holistic approach at the investigations was highlighted.
身体攻击暴力是发病率和死亡率的常见原因,这种情况在不发达国家普遍存在,但不仅限于此。在这类案件中,法医专家的意见对于确定刑罚往往不可或缺。本研究旨在描述受害者的呈现模式,并根据受害者的调查结果评估在形成科学的法医学意见时的优势和局限性。
基于斯里兰卡拉贾马市科伦坡北部教学医院收治的袭击受害者的病例记录,进行了为期四年的回顾性描述性研究。
在400名受害者中,大多数(72%,n = 290)为男性,年龄在21至40岁之间(n = 216)。大多数袭击的原因是突然挑衅(n = 99,25%),其次是先前长期的敌意(n = 89,22%)。大多数(83%)有孤立的钝器伤,且伤势不严重(74%)。防御伤与试图防御(p = 0.000)和锐器伤(p = 0.002)显著相关。袭击的根本原因与致伤武器(p = 0.228)或受伤身体部位(p = [0.195])无显著关联。
尽管损伤的呈现和模式在形成科学意见方面肯定有价值,但该研究确定了法医专家的局限性,并强调了调查时采用整体方法的必要性。