Wijaya Tommy Tanu, Cao Yiming, Weinhandl Robert, Tamur Maximus
School of Mathematical Sciences, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China.
International Center for Research in Mathematics Education, Faculty of Education, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, China.
Heliyon. 2022 May 23;8(6):e09432. doi: 10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e09432. eCollection 2022 Jun.
The 21st century allows the use of e-books to substitute printed books in educational context, thereby adapt teaching and learning to the potentialities of our digital era. Several studies examined the effect of mathematics e-books compared to traditional printed books on students' mathematics achievement, however, the results are still inconclusive. Therefore, this research conducted a meta-analysis to determine the effects of mathematics e-books on students' mathematics achievement. This is a quantitative research with data collected from 17 studies with 26 effect sizes (N = 3115) published between 2010 and 2021. The collected data were used to analyze the moderating effects of publication year, sample size, level education, treatment duration and type of e-books on students' mathematics achievement. The result showed that overall using mathematics e-books has a high effect (g = 0.82) on students' mathematics achievement. Furthermore, using e-Books does not affect students' mathematics achievement in year publication and significantly affects the pre-school level, who are more proficient in using technology. Mathematics e-books are more effective when used for less than 4 weeks and also effective when the sample is less than 30 students. There is no significant difference between non-interactive and interactive mathematics e-books. Moreover, this research provided a detailed description of the findings and implications as well as highlighted some suggestions for future studies.
21世纪使得在教育环境中可以使用电子书来替代纸质书籍,从而使教学适应我们数字时代的潜力。多项研究考察了数学电子书与传统纸质书籍相比对学生数学成绩的影响,然而,结果仍无定论。因此,本研究进行了一项元分析,以确定数学电子书对学生数学成绩的影响。这是一项定量研究,数据收集自2010年至2021年发表的17项研究,共有26个效应量(N = 3115)。收集到的数据用于分析出版年份、样本量、教育水平、治疗时长和电子书类型对学生数学成绩的调节作用。结果表明,总体而言,使用数学电子书对学生的数学成绩有较大影响(g = 0.82)。此外,使用电子书对出版年份的学生数学成绩没有影响,对学前水平的学生有显著影响,因为他们更擅长使用技术。数学电子书使用少于4周时更有效,样本少于30名学生时也有效。非交互式和交互式数学电子书之间没有显著差异。此外,本研究详细描述了研究结果和启示,并突出了对未来研究的一些建议。