Department of Medical Ecology and Hydroclimatology, Gülhane Training and Research Hospital, University of Health Sciences, Ankara, Turkey.
Centre de Recherce Rhumatologique Et Termal, Aix Les Bains, France.
Int J Biometeorol. 2022 Aug;66(9):1829-1839. doi: 10.1007/s00484-022-02323-0. Epub 2022 Jul 2.
We evaluated the quantity and quality of scientific publications linked with water treatments using the Web of Science (WoS) database. The WoS was searching by using the following terms "hydrotherapy," "balneotherapy," "spa therapy," "spa treatment," "creno-balneotherapy," "water treatments," and "aqua therapy," on February 10th, 2022. The recorded data were the total number of articles, year of articles, country of articles, journal, document type, index data, and citation data. Also, the studies performed with natural source mineral water were marked to make a further subgroup analysis through quality and quantity. We obtained 816 articles; 667 (81.74%) were original research articles, and 149 (18.26%) were review articles. A statistically significant and increasing trend was shown in the publication about water treatments (p < 0.01). About three-quarters of the trials were sourced from high-income countries. Italy (n = 98; 12.01%); Turkey (n = 75; 9.19%); Australia (n = 65; 7.97%); Brazil (n = 46; 5.64%); and France (n = 38; 4.66%) were the most productive countries. Calculating the number of articles per million population, Hungary (3.38), Australia (2.53), and Italy (1.64) ranked in the top three. According to 100 billion dollars GDP, the top three countries were Brazil (24.41), Hungary (21.15), and Turkey (10.41). In the average citation calculation, the Netherlands (60.84), Israel (29.86), and Australia (29.06) were in the top three. The International Journal of Biometeorology was the leading journal for publication trials about water treatments. In the subgroup analysis, we found the total number of studies performed with natural source mineral water and non-specified source water trials as 430 and 386, respectively. We also presented that the natural source and non-specified water trials had a statistically significant and increasing trend between 2000 and 2021 (p < 0.01 and p < 0.01, respectively). The trials performed with natural source water mainly were sourced from Italy (n = 79; 18.37%), Turkey (n = 61; 14.19%), France (n = 38; 8.84%), Poland (n = 30; 6.98%), and Hungary (n = 29; 6.74%), the trials performed with non-specified water were sourced from Australia (n = 61; 15.80%), Brazil (n = 46; 11.92%), USA (n = 27; 6.99%), Italy (n = 19; 4.92%), and England (n = 18; 4.66%). The top journal of the natural source water trials was the International Journal of Biometeorology (n = 65; 15.12%), and for the non-specified water trials, it was the International Journal of Sports Physiology (n = 12; 3.11%).Our study presented an increasing trend in trial publications regarding water treatments between 2000 and 2021. Most of the trials were from high and upper-middle-income countries. We suggest that by demonstrating global productivity worldwide, our results can create more scientific attention on this topic and may promote the quantity and quality of the trials.
我们使用 Web of Science(WoS)数据库评估了与水疗相关的科学出版物的数量和质量。WoS 于 2022 年 2 月 10 日使用“hydrotherapy”、“balneotherapy”、“spa therapy”、“spa treatment”、“creno-balneotherapy”、“water treatments”和“aqua therapy”等术语进行了搜索。记录的数据包括文章总数、文章年份、文章国家、期刊、文献类型、索引数据和引用数据。此外,还对使用天然水源矿泉水进行的研究进行了标记,以便通过质量和数量进行进一步的子组分析。我们共获得 816 篇文章;667 篇(81.74%)为原始研究文章,149 篇(18.26%)为综述文章。关于水疗的出版物呈显著且持续增加的趋势(p<0.01)。约四分之三的试验来自高收入国家。意大利(n=98;12.01%)、土耳其(n=75;9.19%)、澳大利亚(n=65;7.97%)、巴西(n=46;5.64%)和法国(n=38;4.66%)是最具生产力的国家。按每百万人口的文章数量计算,匈牙利(3.38)、澳大利亚(2.53)和意大利(1.64)排名前三。按 1000 亿美元 GDP 计算,前三名国家是巴西(24.41)、匈牙利(21.15)和土耳其(10.41)。在平均引用计算中,荷兰(60.84)、以色列(29.86)和澳大利亚(29.06)排名前三。《国际生物气象学杂志》是发表水疗试验的主要期刊。在子组分析中,我们发现使用天然水源矿泉水和非指定水源进行的研究总数分别为 430 项和 386 项。我们还发现,2000 年至 2021 年期间,天然水源和非指定水源试验呈显著且持续增加的趋势(p<0.01 和 p<0.01,分别)。使用天然水源进行的试验主要来自意大利(n=79;18.37%)、土耳其(n=61;14.19%)、法国(n=38;8.84%)、波兰(n=30;6.98%)和匈牙利(n=29;6.74%),使用非指定水源进行的试验来自澳大利亚(n=61;15.80%)、巴西(n=46;11.92%)、美国(n=27;6.99%)、意大利(n=19;4.92%)和英格兰(n=18;4.66%)。天然水源试验的顶级期刊是《国际生物气象学杂志》(n=65;15.12%),而非指定水源试验的顶级期刊是《国际运动生理学杂志》(n=12;3.11%)。我们的研究表明,2000 年至 2021 年间,关于水疗的试验出版物呈上升趋势。大多数试验来自高收入和中上收入国家。我们建议,通过展示全球的生产力,我们的研究结果可以引起对该主题的更多科学关注,并可能促进试验的数量和质量。