Asia-Pacific Centre for Animal Health, Melbourne Veterinary School, Faculty of Veterinary and Agricultural Sciences, The University of Melbourne, Parkville, Australia.
Department of Basic Veterinary Sciences, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine and Animal Science, University of Peradeniya, Peradeniya, Sri Lanka.
Avian Pathol. 2022 Dec;51(6):550-560. doi: 10.1080/03079457.2022.2103396. Epub 2022 Aug 1.
is the primary causative agent of chronic respiratory disease in poultry, and vaccination is the measure most commonly used for its control. Pathological changes caused by are mainly observed in the trachea and air sacs, but assessment of air sac lesions is subjective. Standardized parameters for evaluation of pathological changes, and their reproducibility and discrimination in uninfected and infected groups, are critical when assessing the efficacy of vaccination. This study reviewed and critically appraised the published literature on evaluation of vaccine efficacy against pathological changes caused by in poultry in the trachea and air sacs. A search of four electronic databases, with subsequent manual filtering, identified 23 eligible papers published since 1962 describing the assessment of histopathological changes in the trachea using tracheal lesion scores and/or measurement of tracheal mucosal thicknesses and assessment of gross air sac lesions using lesion scores. Measurement of tracheal lesions proved a more reliable and robust method of assessing disease induced by when compared to assessment of air sac lesions, highlighting the importance of including assessment of tracheal lesions as the primary outcome variable in vaccine efficacy studies. In addition, this study also identified the necessity for use of a standardized model for evaluation and reporting on vaccines to minimize variations between vaccine efficacy studies and to allow direct comparisons between them. Tracheal and air sac lesions have been used to assess vaccine efficacy.The specific parameters and statistical tests used to compare tracheal and air sac lesions vary greatly.Measures of tracheal lesions are more discriminatory than measures of air sac lesions.A standardized model is needed to evaluate vaccines against infection with .
是家禽慢性呼吸道疾病的主要病原体,疫苗接种是其控制的最常用措施。由引起的病变主要观察到在气管和气囊中,但气囊病变的评估是主观的。在评估疫苗接种对的功效时,评估病理变化的标准化参数及其在未感染和感染组中的可重复性和区分度至关重要。本研究综述和批判性评价了自 1962 年以来关于评估疫苗接种对家禽气管和气囊中由引起的病理变化的功效的文献。对四个电子数据库进行了搜索,并随后进行了手动筛选,确定了 23 篇符合条件的论文,这些论文描述了使用气管病变评分和/或测量气管黏膜厚度评估气管组织病理学变化,以及使用病变评分评估气囊大体病变的情况。与气囊病变评估相比,测量气管病变被证明是一种更可靠和稳健的方法来评估由引起的疾病,突出了在疫苗功效研究中纳入气管病变评估作为主要结局变量的重要性。此外,本研究还确定了需要使用标准化模型来评估和报告疫苗,以最大程度地减少疫苗功效研究之间的差异,并允许它们之间进行直接比较。气管和气囊病变已被用于评估疫苗对的功效。比较气管和气囊病变所使用的具体参数和统计检验差异很大。气管病变的测量比气囊病变的测量更具区分力。需要一个标准化的模型来评估针对感染的疫苗。