Department of Emergency Medicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, United States of America.
Department of Emergency Medicine, San Francisco General Hospital, UCSF School of Medicine, San Francisco, California, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2022 Jul 25;17(7):e0271070. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0271070. eCollection 2022.
Although computed tomography (CT) of the abdomen and pelvis (A/P) can provide crucial information for managing blunt trauma patients, liberal and indiscriminant imaging is expensive, can delay critical interventions, and unnecessarily exposes patients to ionizing radiation. Currently no definitive recommendations exist detailing which adult blunt trauma patients should receive A/P CT imaging and which patients may safely forego CT. Considerable benefit could be realized by identifying clinical criteria that reliably classify the risk of abdominal and pelvic injuries in blunt trauma patients. Patients identified as "very low risk" by such criteria would be free of significant injury, receive no benefit from imaging and therefore could be safely spared the expense and radiation exposure associated with A/P CT. The goal of this two-phase nationwide multicenter observational study is to derive and validate the use of clinical criteria to stratify the risk of injuries to the abdomen and pelvis among adult blunt trauma patients. We estimate that nation-wide implementation of a rigorously developed decision instrument could safely reduce CT imaging of adult blunt trauma patients by more than 20%, and reduce annual radiographic charges by $180 million, while simultaneously expediting trauma care and decreasing radiation exposure with its attendant risk of radiation-induced malignancy. Prior to enrollment we convened an expert panel of trauma surgeons, radiologists and emergency medicine physicians to develop a consensus definition for clinically significant abdominal and pelvic injury. In the first derivation phase of the study, we will document the presence or absence of preselected candidate criteria, as well as the presence or absence of significant abdominal or pelvic injuries in a cohort of blunt trauma victims. Using recursive partitioning, we will examine combinations of these criteria to identify an optimal "very low risk" subset that identifies injuries with a sensitivity exceeding 98%, excludes injury with a negative predictive value (NPV) greater than 98%, and retains the highest possible specificity and potential to decrease imaging. In Phase 2 of the study we will validate the performance of a decision rule based on these criteria among a new cohort of patients to ensure that the criteria retain high sensitivity, NPV and optimal specificity. Validating the sensitivity of the decision instrument with high statistical precision requires evaluations on 317 blunt trauma patients who have significant abdominal-pelvic injuries, which will in turn require evaluations on approximately 6,340 blunt trauma patients. We will estimate potential reductions in CT imaging by counting the number of abdominal-pelvic CT scans performed on "very low risk" patients. Reductions in charges and radiation exposure will be determined by respectively summing radiographic charges and lifetime decreases in radiation morbidity and mortality for all "very low risk" cases. Trial registration: Clinicaltrials.gov trial registration number: NCT04937868.
尽管腹部和骨盆计算机断层扫描 (CT) 可为管理钝性创伤患者提供关键信息,但广泛而无区别的影像学检查既昂贵又会延迟关键干预措施的实施,而且还会使患者不必要地暴露于电离辐射中。目前尚无明确的建议详细说明哪些成年钝性创伤患者应接受腹部和骨盆 CT 成像,以及哪些患者可以安全地避免 CT 检查。通过确定能够可靠分类钝性创伤患者腹部和骨盆损伤风险的临床标准,可以带来相当大的益处。通过这些标准确定为“极低风险”的患者没有严重损伤,影像学检查对其没有益处,因此可以避免与腹部和骨盆 CT 相关的费用和辐射暴露,使他们免受伤害。本项全国多中心观察性研究的两个阶段旨在制定和验证使用临床标准来分层评估成年钝性创伤患者腹部和骨盆损伤风险的方法。我们估计,在全国范围内实施严格制定的决策工具,可以安全地减少 20%以上的成年钝性创伤患者的 CT 成像,并减少每年 1.8 亿美元的放射费用,同时加快创伤护理并减少与辐射相关的恶性肿瘤的辐射暴露风险。在入组之前,我们召集了一个由创伤外科医生、放射科医生和急诊医师组成的专家小组,为临床显著的腹部和骨盆损伤制定了一个共识定义。在研究的第一阶段,我们将记录选定的候选标准的存在或不存在,以及钝性创伤受害者队列中是否存在显著的腹部或骨盆损伤。我们将使用递归分区来检查这些标准的组合,以确定一个最佳的“极低风险”亚组,该亚组具有超过 98%的敏感性,排除了 98%以上的阴性预测值 (NPV),并保留了最高的特异性和减少成像的潜力。在研究的第二阶段,我们将在新的患者队列中验证基于这些标准的决策规则的性能,以确保标准具有较高的敏感性、NPV 和最佳的特异性。通过高统计学精度评估 317 例具有显著腹部-骨盆损伤的钝性创伤患者来验证决策工具的敏感性,这反过来又需要对大约 6340 例钝性创伤患者进行评估。我们将通过计算“极低风险”患者腹部-骨盆 CT 扫描的数量来估计 CT 成像的潜在减少量。通过分别汇总放射性费用和所有“极低风险”病例的终生辐射发病率和死亡率的降低来确定费用和辐射暴露的减少。试验注册:Clinicaltrials.gov 试验注册编号:NCT04937868。