Mishra Satish, Laplante-Lévesque Ariane, Barbareschi Giulia, Witte Luc De, Abdi Sarah, Spann Alice, Khasnabis Chapal, Allen Michael
World Health Organization Regional Office for Europe, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Global Disability Innovation Hub, London, United Kingdom.
Disabil Rehabil Assist Technol. 2024 Feb;19(2):474-485. doi: 10.1080/17483107.2022.2099021. Epub 2022 Jul 29.
Globally, assistive technology (AT) is used by over 1 billion people, but the prevalence of needs and access to AT in specific countries or regions is largely unknown. This scoping review summarises the evidence available on the prevalence of needs, access and coverage of AT in the World Health Organisation European Region and the barriers and facilitators to its use.
Relevant publications were identified using a combination of two strategies: 1) a systematic search for AT publications in five scientific literature databases; and 2) consultations with 76 of the Region's AT experts.
The search strategies yielded 103 publications, 62 of them identified by the systematic search. The included publications were predominantly from six countries, and 18 countries were unrepresented. Information on AT use for specific functional impairments was present in 57 publications: AT for hearing impairment in 14 publications; vision in 12; mobility, 12; communication, 11; self-care, 6; and cognition, 2. AT needs for vision and hearing impairment were more likely to be met (1-87% and 5-90%, respectively) compared with communication and cognition impairments (10-60% and 58%, respectively). The barriers and facilitators to AT access described were linked to accessibility, affordability and acceptability.
Data on AT prevalence and coverage are limited in both quantity and quality. Agreed-upon definitions of functional impairment and assistive product categories and standards for data collection are needed to facilitate data comparisons and to build a more representative picture of AT needs and coverage.Implications for rehabilitationComprehensive and disaggregated data concerning the prevalence of needs and coverage of AT is needed to enable the development of responsive policies and actions.The literature available on the prevalence of needs and coverage of AT in the WHO European Region is primarily focussed on a small subset of countries and comparisons between studies are limited due to the use of different data collection strategies.Evidence concerning barriers and facilitators to AT access across countries is more consistent and can be organised across the key themes of accessibility, affordability and acceptability of AT.There is a need for consensus among multiple AT actors on standardised definitions for functional impairment and assistive product categories and standards for data collection to enable a more representative picture to be built of AT needs and coverage across the WHO European Region and globally.
在全球范围内,超过10亿人使用辅助技术(AT),但特定国家或地区对辅助技术的需求程度和获取情况在很大程度上尚不清楚。本综述总结了世界卫生组织欧洲区域内辅助技术的需求程度、获取情况和覆盖范围的现有证据,以及使用辅助技术的障碍和促进因素。
采用两种策略相结合的方式来确定相关出版物:1)在五个科学文献数据库中系统搜索辅助技术相关出版物;2)与该区域76名辅助技术专家进行磋商。
搜索策略共产生103篇出版物,其中62篇是通过系统搜索确定的。纳入的出版物主要来自六个国家,有18个国家未被代表。57篇出版物中包含了关于针对特定功能障碍使用辅助技术的信息:14篇涉及听力障碍的辅助技术;12篇涉及视力;12篇涉及行动能力;11篇涉及沟通;6篇涉及自我护理;2篇涉及认知。与沟通和认知障碍(分别为10 - 60%和58%)相比,视力和听力障碍的辅助技术需求更有可能得到满足(分别为1 - 87%和5 - 90%)。所描述的辅助技术获取障碍和促进因素与可及性、可承受性和可接受性相关。
辅助技术普及程度和覆盖范围的数据在数量和质量上都很有限。需要就功能障碍和辅助产品类别的商定定义以及数据收集标准达成一致,以促进数据比较,并更具代表性地呈现辅助技术的需求和覆盖情况。对康复的启示需要有关辅助技术需求程度和覆盖范围的全面且分类的数据,以制定相应的政策和行动。世界卫生组织欧洲区域内有关辅助技术需求程度和覆盖范围的现有文献主要集中在一小部分国家,并且由于使用不同的数据收集策略,各研究之间的比较有限。各国关于辅助技术获取障碍和促进因素的证据更为一致,并且可以按照辅助技术的可及性、可承受性和可接受性等关键主题进行梳理。多个辅助技术相关行为体需要就功能障碍和辅助产品类别的标准化定义以及数据收集标准达成共识,以便更具代表性地呈现世界卫生组织欧洲区域乃至全球的辅助技术需求和覆盖情况。